Sea Star Cafe

Hidden gem that gets better with age. Great vegan and vegetarian options. Sandwiches, wraps, teas, lemonade, baked goods (not vegan). They also stock Joe's chips.

We've been going here since it was a little nothing on main St. A must
Visit if you're on the island.

Plentiful outdoor seating

Grabbed some Sea Star to take and enjoy on the beach. As someone who can't have gluten or wheat, I was disappointed they didn't offer a GF wrap or other alternative. However, the breadless sandwich was sooo good! Their products are fresh, tasty, and worth it. We showed up right when they opened and they had a line form right away. I can understand why!

I was very excited to find this cafe while visiting Chincoteague. They have something for everyone on this menu, from vegan/vegetarian to sandwiches piled high with the works. I had the special which was turkey with bacon jam and brie on a biscuit. It was mouth watering! My husband got the hummus and pita. Everything was fresh and delicious.

Their Turkey special sandwich was amazing ! Turkey, bacon, avacado, blue cheese Asiago, wow! July 2021.
Also walnut brownie was totally worth it.

Fresh handmade sandwiches. Service was friendly and food was delivered quickly. I really enjoyed eating outside at little picnic tables. Watched the water birds. Good shade.

We came here after waiting and being ignored by the front of house staff over 30 minutes prior at a diner down the road. Although there was a line here shortly after opening, it went quick and was totally worth it. The artisan sandwiches are made fresh, to order, and the way they’re assembled, wrapped and bagged, shows they care about the food served and the customer receiving it. Portions are generous and worth every cent. Customer service was excellent and the gal at the order window was bubbly, polite, and appreciative of our business and tip. We will be back.

Heard about this place and was a bit hesitant to try since we’ve heard & read good reviews about certain restaurants/food places in the area that have let us down. However, this place is absolutely AMAZING! The food is tasty and fresh. Staff was very friendly and attentive. Absolutely and highly recommend Sea Star, and we’ll definitely be coming back.

Friendly staff serve a variety of healthy and tasty sandwiches. Vegan and vegetarian options. Being a vegan, my favourite is the Santa Cruz. Also, homemade soups, chili, and baked goods. Eating at the Sea Star each year I visit the Eastern Shore is one of the biggest things I look forward to! Best sandwich place I've ever eaten at!

Wow. Really good sandwich shop. Good vegetarian options. Had a wonderful Greek salad wrap with a side of their hummus. They said the hummus wouldn't fit in the wrap and I believe them.

Or side seating at picnic tables with umbrellas.
Nice atmosphere. Great music while waiting in line to order.

The place gives a homily feel with a sense of satisfaction after eating the so organic and fresh food ! Should taste the hummus without a miss - it’s so fresh n so perfectly done ....
sandwiches n salads are so superior in quality n design with the menu not missing out what you would look for ....
never miss the place if you in Chincoteague Island :)
Thanks guys for a happy lunch ...