Sea Star Cafe

It's a little pricey but they make a mean sandwich and wrap. Plenty of vegetarian (and non vegetarian) options. Great soups. Tasty flavor of the day iced tea too. Don't forget to ask for your pickle!

My boyfriend and I opted to go here instead our standby, Ray's Shanty, as a good friend of mine had raved about the shrimp salad here. There was a long line even though it was off season. While in line, I commented to another customer that my friend said the shrimp salad was great and she said, "your friend is right". I don't know if it was on off day or because it was off season, but the shrimp salad both my boyfriend and I got, plus 2 bags of chips totaled about $25.00 and was not worth the price. The salad was bland and the shrimp had no flavor, like they were frozen, precooked shrimp from Wal-Mart. Not sure if I will return. I was deeply disappointed based on the reviews I read... I'm giving 2 stars because the location is nice

My sandwich was incredibly fresh and well made, the service was friendly, and the hummus was very good too! Anyone visiting the island would be missing out by not going to sea star.

Best sandwich or wrap on the island! Scrumptious homemade desserts, ice tea and lemonade. In 4 days we had eaten here 3 times.

Absolutely delicious fresh, homemade food. The portions are very generous and sandwiches are loaded with meat. I only got to stop by twice while on vacation but I would have gone every day.

Great choices. Organic and good for you. Soups and sandwiches excellent. Also did made to order. Also had vegan options. One of our 'go to' places while in Chincoteague.

Nice staff with delicious HEALTHY options organic food and vegetarian options. Lots of diff sandwiches and wraps or build ur own. Wish I had found it earlier in my week so I could have went everyday!

Best sandwich place in Chincoteague! It's carry out only, but they have a couple outside tables where you can sit. Or grab your food and drive out to beach at Assateague. And one sandwich will feed two easily. YUM!

We make the trip from Virginia Beach all the way to Chincoteague for bike riding and this restaurant. Everything on the vegan/vegetarian menu is amazing and fresh!

The food is amazing, the atmosphere is great! Great for vegans/vegetarians, but there are also a lot of seafiod/meat options as well! You eat outside next to the cutest little pond with ducks!