Sea Star Cafe

The food is awesome and high quality - very generous portions and fair prices. Unfortunately we waited 40 minutes in line and 30 minutes for our food after ordering. There is no restroom and the outdoor patio/lawn tables are filled with food scraps/trash and therefor bugs. Lovely little spot on the water in the shade, but not a great place for kids by any means.

My wife and I found this little gem while hunting for somewhere to eat something small. There's nothing inherently flashy about the cafe--it's basically a small "shack"/structure that you walk up to, order your meal, and hang around while they pull it together. It has outdoor seating, and there is where the it shines. The place is right on the marsh edge with a clear view of the wildlife. There are three camp tables with umbrella shades and the nearby trees provide additional shade, creating a cool little oasis on a hot day.

Food-wise, the portions are substantial. Order a sandwich, eat half of it in the eating area, and take the other back home or to your hotel. Eat the next day or later--whatever catches your fancy. The food was also fresh and tasty.

We ended up paying just shy of $30 for two sandwiches, a bag of chips, and two drinks so it's not the cheapest of locations, but we think that it was worth it.

It doesn't come with gluten free options (bread, wraps) because they have "not found any that have the quality they want." They will, however, provide a salad bowl for the sandwich with sauce/dressing on the side. It's a little bit awkward to eat, so I wish they would source a covered plat rather than a bowl but, well, it's a minor critique.

Food is delicious. It is carryout only. A few outside tables. Perfect place for a quick lunch with really great handmade sandwiches, salads and soups. It does not look like much from outside - give it a try!

Good portions for the price although it's somewhat limited for a picky eater, there's about a dozen sandwiches & half doz wraps. If I was more open I'd like more on the menu, soup was intriguing. A wrap or 2 I may try as well as another sandwich or 2. My bistro sandwich was good, as described & fresh except on a croissant was a surprise still delicious & the chicken salad was good as well.

Phenomenal food! I had the Baja Wrap. Wish it was a tad more tangy, but it was so fresh and delicious! They even bagged the bread separately from the meat for the sandwich I bought for my kiddos since my son is gluten free and was splitting the sandwich with my daughter. Great service, wonderful food, and I totally recommend stopping if you're in the area.

Food was good but nothing spectacular, especially for the price. Spent about 30-40 minutes there between having our order taken and getting our food. Can definitely get a decent sandwich lunch elsewhere with less of a wait at a lower cost.

Best sandwiches around!!! Fresh ingredients and wonderful staff. The staff went the extra mile to make sure to provide a healthy environment due to the current pandemic. The restaurant has a beautiful and clean outdoor eating area. If you want to get out and be in an open setting with low risk of covid spread, I would totally recommend this establishment.

This place is excellent! Our two sandwiches were great - really delicious ingredients & really generous quantities. And the two iced coffees were delicious as well, perfect after a long afternoon on the beach. We'll definitely come back here again.

This is the BEST lunch place on the whole island. Good-sized sandwiches, with amazing flavor combos. They also tend to have a sandwich/soup of the day, to keep things interesting. The hummus tastes homemade as well.

Wow a gem a must do for me as I am a foodie and they kick it out for me. Of the ballpark that is. Don’t miss this on your way to the beach super desserts super good soups. Love it’s all in house made with loads of love thanks. I travel for this food an hour away just to do and get. The red peppers they just do so well blended with goat cheese and roast beef warmed mmm good. You just don’t know how good it is. The cozy setting by the water super. Hats off to the chef and staff done right. The lettuce here I know what your thinking is the best so crisp and fresh. Not sure how you do it but well done. Chicken salad very good those red peppers love them. Wish you had this sandwich above as a daily special enjoy