Straight From New York Bagels

Definitely not NY bagels but they try.

Stopped by for a nice deli sandwich and was impressed. Calling yourself a NY deli and actually pulling it off is no easy feat but these guys did quite well. Nicely organized menu board with some creative sandwiches and quite a few good looking deli salads that the fellow behind the counter seemed to take a lot of pride in. I had the Philly Steak (I know, not exactly NY deli) and it was a good size loaded up with house-made roast beef. My kid had a simple turkey on bun that they kindly modified for her.
The service itself was amazing, a lot of pride behind the counter and plenty of information provided. The fellow behind the counter (the owner?) practically forced me to try samples of each of his salads (which I gladly obliged) while he told me about each one. A real nice experience.
In addition, they had a nice looking bagel selection and plenty of quick bite options. I plan on stopping back for breakfast so I can see what's doing.
In the end, there are plenty of corporate dining options available nearby but these guys are OUR local deli. Stop by, give them a try and support our local businesses.

I crave my favorite morning breakfast, a bacon and egg on sesame bagel. No one in SWFL makes a bagel like Straight From New York Bagel. Light and airy and delicious. I wish they’d consider opening a third store in Estero.

Excellent bagels. Very busy place but worth the wait. A dozen bagels here is 15 not 12 so we really like the fact we can get a weeks worth in one shot. We stop here weekly.
(People who come from up North and want to complain about 'all things Covid' need to go back up North with their attitudes. This is NOT NYC or NJ. Many of us fled those states to take up a more peaceful and less 'covidcentric' lifestyle. Judge the food, your opinions on 'all things covid' are irrelevant and harm small businesses. Look at your decimated states and stop applying that logic here so you can decimate us.
Sincerely.
A Political Refugee From NJ (now a proud Florida resident)

Tried for the first time two days ago and it was too amazing not to write a review for! I’ve never eaten a better bagel in my life, and that may sound like an exaggeration but it is 100% true. I had a Honey Wheat with just plain old cream cheese and it was the best breakfast i’ve had in quite a long time. Thanks for the amazing breakfast!!!

Hesitant to return due to service.

Great quality bagels, but the service lacked. I called to make an order from this location and upon arrival they did not have it logged. They mentioned I probably called the wrong location... I asked what their phone number is because I had the call logged in my phone and it was the correct number. They took the order again and asked if I remembered the order, luckily I did as I was ordering for the whole office.

They rushed the order out and the food was good, but it would have been nice to have offered a coffee or something while they had me waiting for the order.

Nice place for a good cup of coffee and a bagel. Lunchtime menu also has a lot to offer. I had a ham and Swiss croissant and it was delicious. Try this place!

Staff is terrible. They just have a blank stare. No effort to serve the customer. I order a half a dozen bagels. I was handed a bag of bagels that I didn't know what was in it. In a typical place you pick your bagels. When I told them I wanted to pic the bagels the girl behind the counter was lost and question me to her coworkers. After I was able to get the bagels I wanted I asked for the tub of cream cheese I paid $5 for, expensive in my opinion. I was then directed across the restaurant to where I had to grab it out of a cooler, that's fine I have no problem doing so, but give me a heads up of where I need to retrieve the items I purchased. Don't think I'll return. Hope the bagels are better then the service.

Best bagels ever!! Awesome pastries, a delicious assorted coffees🤗

This was our first visit to the bagel store and we were impressed. I got a muffin and my husband got a bagel with cream cheese.

The muffin was huge and lasted me all day with nibbles at the beach. His bagel was so stuffed with cream cheese, that when he took one bite and a big chunk of cream cheese plopped to the table. Knowing how loaded the bagel would be, next time I think we'll get two bagels, but only one with cream cheese because there was plenty there for both of us.

Prices were a little high but with the quantity it was worth it. We will be back because it seems like a perfect thing to grab to take to the beach.