Search

Amenities

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Delivery
  • In-store pickup
  • In-store shopping
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in

Straight From New York Bagels Reviews - 100

3.6
Quality
5.0
Location
5.0
Price
4.0
Service
4.5
Mary Klucinec

The bagels, cream cheese and breakfast sandwiches are always awesome and fresh. The service is sometimes hit and miss. Some days they are very fast and some days they are very slow. It seems they have high turn over rate of employees and I haven't seen the owner there in quite sometime.



I've never had their lunch sandwiches but their egg salad was not in a covered container in the cooler and tasted terribly of "refrigerator".

Kai Zeyher

Been coming here for a couple of months now. The best bagels in town for sure, and the only place you can find real nova, locally sourced coffee, dairy, espresso. And serving real Taylor pork roll-- talk about straight from the NE!

On top of that, personal friendly service makes this location a must visit for any breakfast lover!

Susan McBride

Good bagels but very expensive. On the north shore of Massachusetts we have Bagel world and the bagels taste the same as straight from New York but they're $9.90 for 13 instead of $19.90 for 15. Bagel World cuts them for free. Straight from New York $3.00 cutting fee.

Christa Whelan

Love this place! If you want an authentic NY bagel you have to come check this place out. Always packed on the weekends so be prepared to wait. It's counter service but they do have a nice little seating area.

Lynn Finnegan

Best bagels this side of New York City. Arrive early so you don't miss out on your favorite bagel. Mine is french toast.

Jackie Anderson

I've been here a couple times and the counter service is definitely lacking. The staff could be friendlier and more knowledgeable about the food. The bagels themselves are good, but I think the pricing for sandwiches is too high.

taylor

I went to the bagel place at 9:30 am, i had to wait 30 min, which isn’t the worse thing but then they forgot my order and the people behind me got there order first, i ordered just one plain bagel toasted. It wasn’t even rapped. worst experience ever.

Daniel Arango

I'm that guy that orders the usual bagel with the same stuff—butter,ham, and cheddar cheese HOT— at quality bagel shops all over NYC and other spots around Florida, and I'll tell you what...fuggedaboutit.

We moved from Brooklyn to Naples and this place makes the best New York style bagels in North Naples and, dare I say, all of Southwest Florida.

These guys have it down to a science!

The service, the bagels, the people. HECK. even the orange juice is good and their literally across the street!

I'm starting to wonder if they really are bringin em straight from NY myself...

Marissa Ross

My first time in, looking for a quick breakfast on an off day for me. I was in a terrible mood and was helped by a girl named chelsea. She completely made me do a 180 on my entire day and made me smile!! Such a sweet girl, amazing customer service. I will definitely be back when I'm in the area. Thanks Chelsea!!

Michael Bagarozzi

This place is so overpriced!!!! I’m a New Yorker and bagels from their are $13-14 a dozen. $22 is crazy and they’re just avg. a definite ripoff

Add Review

Cleanliness
Comfort
Staff
Facilities
Your Score
Click here or drop files to upload