Straight From New York Bagels

Check this place out if you want a great tasting bagel that is stuffed ( sandwich, cream cheese or other filling).
The place is tucked in a little plaza off Immokolee Road with a sign that just says Bagels. Depending on when you go you may hit the rush. I've been here a few times over a couple years with same good quality ( pre/during covid & now). Staff is real quick at ringing people up too!

True to the name and truer still to the mission these bagels are straight from New York and dining-in actually takes you to New York! Represents the best of a bagel spread with plenty of options and a veggie friendly menu. My bagel was exceptionally delicious, I could taste everything in balance, not too much cream cheese or too little filling. They know how to make them here. I think dining-in is a better experience because the friendly crowd and environment is like a visit to New York. Coffee is just as good. If you want to visit NY, go to Straight From New York Bagels.... hahahah! Thank you team!

I wanted to try a few different things before I wrote this. Coffee good. Good customer service. Never had to wait too long for food. Never messed up my order. Bagels aren’t NY, and I don’t care about the “old world method” they brag about, they are mid at best. For the price they charge they could at least put two eggs on the sandwich. Every other place around here does. “Kaiser roll” was trash. There’s nothing New York about this place. When you attach that moniker to your name there’s a certain expectation you should live up to and they live up to none of that. There’s much better places to go to around here where you get better quality and more for your money. I am so disappointed.

Great variety of bagels here! We had Jalapeno cheddar and Egg Everything bagel. They are so yummy that I don't put any butter or creamcheese on them, just lightly toasted. Downside is there is no iced coffee with the exception of bottled Cold Brew in the cooler. The price is not labeled well and turnes out it was over six dollars for a small bottle. They do offer fountain sodas and free cups for water.

This place is great! I went with my sister (her favorite bagel place) her bagel came with a great amount of cream cheese! They were very careful about my nieces allergies which was very nice. I had a breakfast sandwich that tasted super fresh on a soft toasted Kaiser roll. I highly recommend giving this place a try. The staff is also extremely nice and friendly and it's a nice, clean and calm place to go.

In the world of bagel shops in Southwest Florida, this place has to be at the top of all of them
Tucked in a small mini mall off of Immokalee, this place can fill you every bagel need, including a good selection of breakfast and lunch sandwiches.
Give them a try, get one toasted with a smear.

Bagel was good. They are short staffed, like everywhere post hurricane, so use your patience. I ordered a breakfast sandwich with egg whites, tomato and spinach. After waiting..... I finally had one of the workers hand me a bag and said, " they told you we were out of spinach?". Nope, no they didn't. Would have appreciated that piece of information when I ordered, would have adjusted my selection.

Awful experience in this nightmare of a bagel spot. Waited in line 30 minutes for 7 bagels. When I finally ordered the incompetent counter woman took my order, I payed and then stepped to the right to get bagels. She then asked what I ordered. I told her 6 everything and I plain. And she said no 5 everything and 1 plain. So she didn't remember what I ordered but had the nerve to tell me that the order I get regularly isn't what I ordered???? Went Bancel and forth telling me it wasn't what I said until I finally said it's what I need though so whatever we need to de to make that happen, let's do that! What terrible customer service! Get order wrong then argue with customer on how they got it wrong but don't offer remedy????? If I could they wouldn't even get one star.

Coming back to edit this review because they have been doing so poorly lately I just can’t bring myself back. Pay attention to the orders, people!!! Don’t forget who comes in and who gets what. You guys have people working there who shouldn’t be placed where they are and it shows. How hard is it to toast a bagel?!

Stacked Taylor ham and Cheese with the egg fried perfectly on a hard roll. Best taylor ham sandwich I've have in a long time. Good stuff.