Search

Amenities

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Delivery
  • In-store pickup
  • In-store shopping
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in

Straight From New York Bagels Reviews - 100

3.6
Quality
5.0
Location
5.0
Price
4.0
Service
4.5
Shawn Flaherty

Awesome!!! If you have ever eaten at a real NYC bagel shop then you know how delicious not only the bagels are but the sandwiches and breakfast sandwiches are as well. This is an amazing trip in time to a NYC bagel shop in Naples, Fl!!! Staff is awesome, food is awesome every time!!! I absolutely love the breakfast sandwiches first thing in the morning every time I'm in Naples. This is a delicious must visit!!!!

Richmon Smith

Best breakfast spot in naples for a quick sandwich! But don't sleep on there lunch menu also tho! There pastrami and corned beef is top caliber!

Steph Hirshberg

Great bagels and great customer service. Saw you at Sanibel farmers market on Easter Sunday! The jalapeño cheddar was amazing. And thanks for the Easter cheer!

William Iseman

OMG Just had a pork roll egg and cheese on a croissant. It was awesome. We are originally from New Jersey been down here 11 years and have not found a bagel shop that has bialys or pork roll. If anybody lives off or near immokalee I highly recommend this shop.

Mark Anthony

This place not only has the best tasting bagels, but the bread for sandwiches is really good.
Meat is Boarshead. It cost some $ but is probably the best in town...and it's consistantly the same !

Cape Cod Beach Bum

Love this breakfast place! Bagels are delicious...French Toast is our family favorite along with the very creamy creme cheese! Wont be disappointed!

John Vogel

The best bagels I've had in my 21 years in Florida. Just going through my reviews. After this review I had a horrible counter experience here in October. With counterson and manager. Bagels are great. But, I will never step foot in this establishment again. Found another bagel shop, just as good, with much friendlier service.

Brady Mayfield

If I could give this review negative stars, I would. It's a true "taste of New York", right down to the "I don't give a damn about the customer" type service. I ordered 2 bagels, 1 toasted and 1 not and both with cream cheese. I waited while 3 sets of customers came in and ordered cooked sandwiches. They were all sitting and eating before I received my order. Sorry to break it to you but that is completely unacceptable and I will never return. Why would I? It's not like they make the only bagels in the area. Go somewhere else that cares about you and gives the service you're paying for.

Update: 72 hours after reaching out per the owner's request via Facebook messenger, still no reply. I think that proves my point about this business and it's lack of customer service.

Tim Olson

Get the everything bagel or the Italian on an everything bagel cannot go wrong. This is the Italian on an everything bagel Just the Way Comes so delicious!

Khrystie Gonzalez

Breakfast done right!!! Ive been coming here for over 8 years and its still one of my favorite places! Bagels are always fresh, the customer service is great and its always clean. I always get a bagel sandwhich and the best part is there is no microwave! Everything is made on the griddle. You will love anything off the menu.

Add Review

Cleanliness
Comfort
Staff
Facilities
Your Score
Click here or drop files to upload