Sclafani's New York Bagels and Bread

Would give zero stars if possible… ordered this morning; my husband’s bacon egg and cheese bagel was cold & my bacon egg and cheese bagel had no egg or cheese. Not sure how that’s possible. Definitely a waste of $ attempting to get breakfast here for the first time….

I keep trying this place and it keeps disappointing. A few days ago I got my sandwich but it didn’t have cheese. Today I asked for extra cheese and I was charged for extra cheese but yet again no cheese. This is the 4th time this has happened and at this point there’s no reason for me to try again. Definitely a disappointment

Went for a late breakfast & each of us ordered a different bagel with different topping. Everyone's order was perfect, with the exception of my daughter's that had TOO MUCH lox! Usually places skimp on the lox, but not here! We'll be back before we head home. Staff was extremely nice & took the time to converse with us as we were eating. Very friendly place!

Good coffee. Good bagels. Too much cream cheese. I'll bet there was 10 oz of cheese on a single bagel. I saved off most of it and have been using it for days. Would have liked the bagel toasted but forgot to ask.

The bagels are delicious! Toasted perfectly and so yummy!

My one complaint is that they are using styrofoam plates. 1. We live in the 21st century and we all know how wasteful that is and how they just fill up our landfills. 2. Not a single person was actually eating off their plate. They all just unwrapped their bagels and ate them off the wrapper. Ditch the wasteful products and this place would be even better!

Edit: They have switched to paper bags! Now all they need is recycling bins to match.

Really long line but worth the wait. I had the egg and bacon bagel! Yummmmmm.
I did see people walking in and picking up orders, so I will definitely try that next time.

Good bagels and food. But they are staffed primarily by teenagers and service is god awful slow. They also encourage pre ordering but leave their phone off the hook to discourage additional orders.

Waited 40 mins for a bagel and coffee.

Bagels are delicious; sandwiches are hit and miss. The pastrami was excellent, the steak and cheese was disgusting. It came with toppings not on the menu, such as tomato. The meat and cheese was piping hot, the onions and peppers were lukewarm, and the tomato, lettuce, and mayo were ice cold. These sensations together, combined with bread that fell apart while dripping with grease and water, were very unappealing. Stick to the bagels.

SO HAPPY TO FIND REAL BAGELS IN WINCHESTER. HAD A PORK ROLL EGG AND CHEESE ON SESAME AND IT WAS AWESOME. SO HAPPY WE FOUND YOU. AND THEBAGUETTE AND PEPPERONI ROLL WERE EXCELLENT. N.J. WHO LOVE MY PR,E,CH SAMMY.

So my wife is a Brooklyn girl. Born and raised. We've been hunting for authentic NY bagels for so long. We've found a bagel shop on the greater east side of Cleveland and this weekend we're down in VA visiting her family. Her brother tells us about Sclafanis. Immediately we open the yelp app to read the reviews. There wasn't any review under 5. So we knew we had to visit them.

Onto my review, we arrive at the shop, it's close to 11 so we expect it to be busy, and I won't knock them on this because they actually served all of the customers with some great efficiency. They have a pretty nice menu and even serve lunch. The interior is very well put together. They have about 7 or so tables I believe? No booths. Their bagel display is what really draws you even at 11 when some other places may be low on certain bagels, their display was still fully stocked. Nobody will say to you "oh I'm sorry we're out of that right now". Employees are very friendly and it seems genuine, it seems as if they actually enjoy their job which is good.

Now on to the bagel. I ordered a lox on an everything bagel. My wife suggested it because she knows I'm a salmon lover. And, oh, my, God. It was a flavor explosion. The bagel was so fresh. I didn't even need to chew the bagel to get the entire flavor of it. The lox itself was amazing and the veggies on it were so fresh. The sandwich itself wasn't rushed so when I unwrapped it, it didn't fall apart. I could go on and on and on about the bagel itself but I think I'd run out of words.

Overall I would tell any and everyone to come here. Bagel lover or not. My wife says it's definitely an authentic NY bagel shop. And I would take her word for it easily. COME HERE IMMEDIATELY