Coffee Mill Roasters

Had a lovely experience at Coffee Mill Roasters. First off, the road directly in front is blocked off for the restaurants to have outdoor seating which is AMAZING! The interior was a little small and crowded, but felt like a proper coffee shop.

When we walked in the owner (presumably) greeted us and asked what he could get us. I ordered a medium coffee with cream and had witty/sarcastic & fun banter with him. He explained that his coffee was sourced from better roasters than the big chains and that I wouldn't need a lot of creamer, to which he was right! I didn't use as much creamer as I typically do and the coffee was smooth with no bitterness.

My gf ordered a tea latte with oat milk and after a little more banter, she received her drink as well. We looked at the many deli cases full of delicious baked goods but ended up not ordering anything. We realized too late that there were gluten free options but were in a rush and had to leave.

We also noticed there was a case for gelato which we would love to try!

All in all a great experience! Will try to come back next time we're in town!

Such a nice spot for coffee and desserts!

They have many options for drinks I wish I could have tried all of them but I was only passing by. The cashier, who I assume is the owner based on other reviews was very lively and took care of my order quick.

I sat outside in the closed off section where the town hosts live music.

This is a Coffee lovers happy place! Great coffee, treats, smoothies and protein shakes! Owner Adel is very kind & professional. I ordered the lavender latte and was extremely satisfied. Come visit and support this local coffee shop.

I can understand the effort in roasting to capture the aroma and flavors of beans, but when it’s brewed into drip coffee, it’s been watered down too much, losing all the effort. I’d recommend to reduce the water amount and reduce the size of serving if necessary to manage cost.

Very cute place with excellent coffee! We had 2 iced cold brew coffees and they were nice & strong. We ended up buying a bag of coffee to take home. Absolutely loved the owner - he was so kind! We will return!

Cute little coffee shop, Lavender latte was really good. Service could be little better.

I have to say. I enjoy the coffee here. But the attached photo was a cookie I got (picture is as purchased). $3.50. For this? It was accompanied by a 3% “convenience fee” and the request for a “tip.”

It's not worth talking about how good the coffee is when the owner is such a rude and unpleasant person. He’s always yelling and mistreating his employees, and he seems to be purely mean and heartless. I gave another chance today, but right away just witnessed the owner treating his employee poorly, and it's no wonder he is always looking for help. Who wants to be around such a terrible human being? I won't be coming back.

Super cute coffee shop and bakery! The cheesecake is rich and flavorful. The owner was friendly. I will mos def be back.

Instagram @KenKooltho

I don’t live in Millburn but I workout around the corner from Coffee Mill Roasters and after every workout I drop by for the best latte; and I buy coffee and fresh local honey for home. Adel is the owner, he works long days, and he’s rarely not there. Support local small businesses! Starbucks gets my money everywhere else, but never in Millburn!