Coffee Mill Roasters

What a great and friendly place to have a cup of coffee. The pastries are superb! Will def be back!

Extraordinary coffee, quaint atmosphere, perfect stop for your caffeine fix. Highly recommended.

As a devoted coffee drinker, I’m always looking for the best coffee in town. Well, it was a nice surprise to discover The Coffee Mill Roasters which specializes in freshly roasted coffee from different origins. I was impressed with their high-quality coffee, appetizing pastries and warm ambiance. The owner, Gennaro Raimo, is very friendly. It was obvious that he takes pride in serving gourmet coffee with a finer aroma, richer flavor, and more body than Starbucks. The incredible selection of pastries, quiches, empanadas and soups are made in house or by the renowned Balthazar bakery (delivered freshly every day). If you haven’t stop yet by this special place, I recommend doing it soon.

The Bakalava was delicately delicious! This is a gem of a coffee house and dessert cafe. You are missing something if you do not patronize such a wonderful coffee shop. I drove 2 hours home with my cappuccino and there was foam still lingering in my cup when I arrived. Quality and service are the intention of this owner. A must stop and support your local business. I will visit every time I drive thru but next time I am buying more bakalava!

Excellent music, incredible service, and employees that talked to us as if we were long-time friends. The coffee was outstanding (for our South American standards), and roasted right there in a really hip establishment. Cheers from Ecuador!

Stopped in after running at the Orange Reservoir. The coffee is expertly prepared and wonderful. I got a hot coffee and the other in my party got a cold brew. No line on Saturday morning because the sheep were all at Starbucks and Dunkin. This was infinitely better and not a chain. Support small businesses!

Great coffee and customer service. Would recommend in a heartbeat, owner is genuinely friendly as well. Accidentally walked into the store after hours thinking it was open, owner still was willing to serve me. I was very pleased that evening.

My girlfriend and I took a trip into beautiful downtown Millburn. During our stroll around and after lunch we decided we wanted coffee. (No stroll is complete without a cup of coffee) It was such a tough decision with so many choices around! Finally we were attracted to a small coffee shop and it was this one! I got the cold brew and my lady friend choose the iced latte. Both were exceptional! Full of flavor and full bodied but not overly strong! Will definitely visit Millburn soon and this is sure to be one of our stops! Enjoy it everyone! Look like a champ in front of your girls and choose this spot. They will think you are a genius!

Cozy and vibrant coffeeshop with great quality drinks. I got the Iced French Toast Latte and it was amazing! They have Balthazar pastries and Mediterranean pastries like goulash (meat or spinach)!

The person who served me today was very rude. He brought up the fact that he belonged to a certain religious group and how muslims were cruel to his people and went on to make assumptions about how people read the Islamic religious texts to “Just read it and not to find the truth”. I will not be returning to this bakery and I would hope that the owner or whoever is in charge ensures that customers are not religiously persecuted by the workers here.