Coffee Mill Roasters

This is my fav coffee place in Millburn. Their coffee is always on point.

Go there often to support local businesses, not a regular though. I gave two stars because to be fair most of times when I go there people who work there are nice until today. The guy at the counter was so rude. I could have given 5 stars but what happened today just ruined it. Definitely won’t go back.

Wonderful European style coffee with a romantic atmosphere.

happy little find on my door dash, was looking for a bright little eatery and i found it. great for that quick bite and a cup of coffee. the flavors are fabulous. i was so impressed after the 1st order, i placed another the next day and was equally pleased. and even thought they may have been out of stock on what i was ordering, the replacement item was just perfect. i trust their choices and will let them surprise me anytime!

Coffee was not great and when we went to sit by the water fountain behind their complex of buildings, the coffee shop owner came out to tell us we can't use them even though its more than 20 feet from their business.

Jokes on them I sit there when their business is closed all the time.

I stopped by here this past Saturday (6/12) to grab a coffee before running some errands. This was my first time at Coffee Mill Roasters.

Ordered a cappuccino and a cold brew, along with a slice of the spinach and feta pie. The pie was AMAZING--warm, savory and rich. The coffee, however? Both were icky, and certainly not worth the $4+ I paid for each. The cold brew was (somehow) both sour and bitter, and it wasn't because of add-ins because I got it black.

The cappuccino was scalding hot and I burnt my tongue. Once it was cool enough to actually taste, the coffee also somehow tasted bitter and sour. It was particularly odd, because the milk foam was normal, but the liquid below was not drinkable.

Really disappointed in this experience. I contemplated going back for a refund or a new drink, but the single cashier/barista was working alone and there were a few people on line/waiting for service. I also felt bad--it could be that the barista was poorly trained, and didn't know how to properly extract the espresso? But that wouldn't explain the icky cold brew.

Either way, I'm sad to be leaving such a poor review. I may pop in for more spinach pie in the future, but I will not bother giving the drink menu a second chance.

I doordashed my order and it was absolutely delicious!! The store called me because they didn’t have my monkey bread and even threw in another free bakery item. The brownies literally were so soft and melted in your mouth! The coffee tasted absolutely fresh and the customer service was astounding. Thank you Coffee Mill Roasters for being opened to everyone in this time!

The coffee is always fresh & delicious. The owner is very kind & recognizes us because we come in at least once a week. Amazing location & coffee!

Best coffee around. It makes Starbucks taste like 7/11. Seriously though, this place is legitimately better and the coffee is noticeably more fresh. The owner is a really nice guy. You should also try the homemade pastries.

In the words of Al Pacino, “This is good coffee.”