New Glarus Bakery
Amenities
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Curbside pickup
- Delivery
- Drive-through
- In-store pickup
- In-store shopping
- Takeout
New Glarus Bakery Reviews - 100
4.4
Quality
5.0
Location
5.0
Price
4.0
Service
4.5
Cathy Krahn
DELICIOUS 😋 The rhubarb bar was absolutely amazing. I wanted to try so much more especially their cheesecakes. Their mocha's we're delicious and not overly sweet. Great staff as well.
Horacio Padilla
Great place to visit if you're in New Glarus. The turtles are THE item I always buy and in bulk LOL
Lori Veldhuis (McVeldy)
This bakery is AMAZING! cookies are so good-- (my favorite is Cherry Oat Bars)-- they have a crazy big selection that changes seasonally. Yesterday we tried the Cranberry Cheesecake slices, and that might be the best dessert I have ever eaten anywhere. Staff are so friendly, prices are good too.
Toby Stevenson
There is a reason this place is one of the oldest bakeries. Amazing items, fantastic custom cakes, and helpful staff. I haven't tried their coffee yet, but plan to on my next visit.
Catherine Sconniegirl
So many yummy treats! Today they were offering BOGO dozen cookies. Absolutely delish! The cheesecake also looked especially amazing.
Lexie R
So many sweets to choose from. I wanted 1 of everything.
The donuts were OK, the sandlissen were amazing. The apricot, lemon and raspberry pockets are great on their own as well as with coffee/tea.
Directress Studio
I go all over the nation, but This has always been my favorite bakery! No one can compete. If you can't decide: go with the cream horn. Full cakes are worth it too! Simple ingredients. Fresh. Excellent customer service.
Dylan Jamieson
One of my favorite places on earth. Really good baking. Whenever I travel to Wisconsin this is where I get my bakery items. The coffee is quite good too but it's really about the baked goods. The square donuts are especially tasty
Kelly Stogner
Everything was fabulous! Cream cheese stuffed donuts, apple bread, Swiss bread, rum balls, lemon cookies, try it all!
Cheryl Gruber
Amazing! I ordered some treats for my mom and Anna was so incredible! I was kept informed when the order was ready to ship (after she changed the shipping date at my request). Everything arrived so fresh and impeccably packed. Mom loved it all and we will order again.
Amazing service, yummy treats and great customer service. I would say that is the trifecta!!