Otter Creek Bakery & Deli

New owners have made a world of difference. Great coffee. Good service. Love the croissants and the Otter paw. Before it didn't smell or look like anything was being freshly made, now the kitchen is a hub of activity and the place smells amazing.

I’m not one to write reviews but as a vegetarian I rarely find good sandwiches and the Vermonter sandwich from this bakery is ABSOLUTELY something to write home about. Goat cheese with fresh veggies on delicious bread. The cookies, coffee, and hot chocolate were also fantastic as were the staff. 10/10 highly recommend. Can’t wait to go back someday soon!

Don't waste your money! Ordered a cheesecake for mother's day and to say we were disappointed would be an understatement. It was grossly overcooked and had an unpleasant texture. Strawberry orange flavors came across as acidic/chemical/ almost soapsy. Will not be going back.

Super service, great coffee and the pièce de résistance the “Otter Paw”

Awesome place! The bread is great, and the sandwiches are huge. Cookies are good too! Also a really nice staff. I had zero complaints and a great experience. The actual bakery smells really good too!

We had two breakfasts at this wonderful place while we were visiting Middlebury. The first day we ordered an otter paw and an almond orange croissant. Both were absolutely delicious and very fresh! The second day we got a couple of breakfast paninis on rye bread. They were also delicious but huge! We split the first one and brought the other home to heat up for breakfast the next day! Highly recommend!!

I have never been disappointed here. Their sandwiches are loaded with fresh, local ingredients. Their pastries and desserts are made with combined decades of experience, and it really shows. Their employees are always polite and professional, but still warm and friendly. It's really hard to overstate how great this place is.

These guys & gals know how to make a sandwich! Nothing is worse than ordering lettuce on your sandwich and getting one flimsy leaf. Here you get lettuce you can sink your teeth into. Nothing is worse than ordering crispy bacon on your sandwich, and getting flimsy, greasy junk. (These things happen for me more often than not at other sandwich places.) Here- crispy bacon that crunches - yes! And their bread and cookies are excellent. Best is their consistency: we've been here many times, and it's always this good. You otter try it!

The food is good and it is reliable. The service is lovely and super quick.

Lovely place with good coffee and very friendly staff. Sandwiches are skimpy on the meat not trimmed well and pricey for the quality. Pastries are almost always great. But watch the cookies not always up to par. Fruit tart is exceptional.