Otter Creek Bakery & Deli

Would give 3.5 Stars. Cute little sandwich shop and bakery with a lot of menu options, including vegetarian options. Sandwiches had nice flavor, but bread wasn’t great. The Rainbow Veggie Sandwich was more unique. We also got the Lemon Pecan cookie, which was pretty tasty. I would go back again for lunch or a sweet treat.

This place is somewhere between a 3 and 4 … the food is fresh. The bread is so-so. It would probably taste better toasted. Also, we ordered ham & cheese croissants. They warmed one up and gave the other cold. Weird place.

The women who helped me Dec 22nd about 2:30 were both great. The lady at the counter, and the lady in the kitchen. They were both helpful, friendly, and cheerful.

I was torn between a 4 and a 5. Firstly, the parking is trash. I hate parallel parking. Hate it so much. Side of the road parking makes me feel like I'm taking over the street. The sandwich options are so overwhelming but they do list them in a way that makes chaotic sense. There are also baked good options (bakery and deli, imagine that). I got an oat bar that has a nice creamy something to it. My boyfriend got a Magic Bar (also known as a Hello Dolly in my family/community). The sandwiches, they do not skimp by any means. The price is a bit up there, I think it was late $30 something, but thats for a Vermonter and a Otter Creek sub, Magic Bar, Oat Square, and Cocoa Granola. So very reasonable broken down. The employees went into the lines to ask what did they want to move everything smoothly. There are little pagers for people to wait outside, in two covered porches. The one down by the street is quaint, classic New England/Vermont store front picnic table. All in all, really good. A lot of options. Overwhelmingly so. The number of options might be the only reason I knock it down to 4.5, too much going on. Not necessarily bad, just hard when it's crowded.

One of the best dirty chai’s I have ever had came from here. The staff is super nice, the building is clean, AND it is wheelchair accessible. Love coming here to treat myself and my friends. Highly recommend.

Otter Creek made the cake and cupcakes for our wedding and they were DELICIOUS!! Everything was absolutely incredible, we received so many compliments. They even handled the delivery and setup which was a huge huge help. We can't wait to go back and eat more cupcakes—highly recommend!!

This place is pretty good. I never experienced any issues until yesterday. Purchased a salted caramel cake yesterday.
The cake was burnt and it was hard. We were very disappointed.

A go-to spot for pastries/cookies, great sandwiches, and desserts for special occasions. Haven’t ever gone wrong with a Norwegian sandwich or hummus pocket here. And they offer a variety of coffee/espresso drinks now too. Lots of outdoor seating options! Love Otter Creek Bakery ❤️

The breakfast egg sandwiches are amazing! The bacon is good quality and the cheese is definitely from Vermont! The best breakfast sandwich I’ve ever had!

I have mostly enjoyed this place. I do have to say though this is not a Honey Bun. I love your bakery! But you can not take a wheat roll with raisins and call it that. Maybe it should be called sweetened dinner roll with sugar on top.