Otter Creek Bakery & Deli

This place is great. Delicious food. And they were exceptionally accommodating and honest about how my partner could avoid any trace of dairy from shared equipment (the slicer, which cuts meats and cheese) for his severe food allergy. And have great vegan and gluten free options. Such a gem for us to find.

Sandwiches get all three stars. 2 really yummy (although they didn’t have panini) sandwiches and 2 decent coffees for under $35: another star. Nice outdoor seating in a great location. Interiors can be better. Service, presentation, can be better.

Good cookies ... A home made taste at last in this country ! Quality over quantity. JK ;-)
PS: and good Expresso also !

I was very disappointed with my experience. They had no panini,were
out of pita bread for falefal sandwich, no baguettes for roast beef, settled for a salad that came in a togo container that didn't work out and sandwich bread sliced so thin it fell apart. Should stick to coffee
and pastry. Staff was helpful.

I've been going here for over 10+ years now. Generally, the food and sweets are delicious. Every once in a while, however, you'll get a baked good that is so sugary that you can only eat half, and you'll start shaking from the sweetness. Just be aware, the sweet looking treats are REALLY sweet.

Their breakfast panini is amazing. Personal add on: tomato and avo; it really is filled with delicious breakfast flavor!

Also, everything tastes better in Vermont

Got my first cake there. The best I have ever had. I will definitely be getting them here from now on. Buttercream just melts in your mouth.

I normally don't bother with reviews but this place deserves only the best from their customers. This is hands-down the cutest, most delicious bakery I have ever been to in my entire life. The coffee was amazing, the pastries were flaky and tender and perfectly sweet (we shared the apple turnover, maple Danish, & Otter claw), and the people were ridiculously friendly. If you are ever in Middlebury (which is also adorable), please please please do yourself a favor and stop in here.

Service was fast and my sandwich delicious. Their coffee was mediocre though. I got a cappuccino and the milk tasted burned. If you stick to pastries and sandwiches though, you'll be fine. Everything is fresh and done to order. Extra props for cleanliness and the covid restrictions in place. They somehow managed to make the bakery feel both safe and normal!

Baked goods were ok, coffee wasnt so exciting and the wifi didn't work for me. . .