Amenities
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
- Wheelchair-accessible parking lot
- Takeout
Boxcar Barney's Reviews - 100
4.7
Quality
5.0
Location
5.0
Price
4.0
Service
4.5
Sign In
Login to 
Real Coffee Club
Real Coffee ClubLogin with your favorite social account for easy sign in & registration.
Login with Google Login with Facebook Login with Twitter Login with Discord Login with LinkedIn
Michael Roberts
We all ordered smalls. That is more than enough. The portions are huge...
Emily Hanson
Soft serve was great! Everyone there. I ordered a twist.
Stacey Ostien
Great service and a great selection. Best we have had in the area, and we will be back for more soon.
Rick Swiger
HUGE Ice cream scoops!!!
Nathan Jackson
Hands down best ice cream around!! Their soft serve is so smooth!
Joseph Cordaro
I’m in Mayville a few days a year and always stop at Boxcar Barney’s.
Wendy Hurd
Great flavors! Big portions!
Keith Burton
Generous helpings of terrific ice cream in a beautiful setting. Friendly young servers.
sandra carter
Good ice cream! Large portions.
daniel caruso
Great ice cream 🍦
Large portions.