Search

Amenities

  • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair-accessible parking lot
  • Takeout

Boxcar Barney's Reviews - 100

4.7
Quality
5.0
Location
5.0
Price
4.0
Service
4.5
Ariel Cartwright

Boxcar Barney's hasn't seen better days! This ice cream/sandwich shop has undergone a wonderful transformation this season. The building has been cleaned up, the tables are all new, there are beautiful potted plants brightening up the space, they play modern music, and the menu has been revised. They offer more ice cream choices than I have ever seen offered at any ice cream shop I've ever visited and their portions are very generous (I would suggest ordering a baby size or a small, anything larger might be too much to finish). They have even added a space to play corn hole; I thought that was a clever addition.
For anyone who hasn't eaten at Barney's before, I think you'll really enjoy the view of the lake while you eat right at Barney's, or it's just a short walk to the Lakeside Park across the street.

Patrick Castle

Omg I'm a huge fan of them now. Awesome ice cream. Almost better than sx.....

Michael Holub

Omg! Biggest scoops of ice cream I have ever seen. Great ice shoppe. It's a small place, so careful when you drive by it.

Andy Brown

Great ice cream! Good sizes and good prices. We were driving by a saw a line of people waiting for ice cream. That was a pretty good indicator it was a local favorite. We were not disappointed at all.

Susan D.

Loved this place! They offer hard ice cream plus soft serve including frozen yogurt. Waffle cones were delicious. Portions were enormous. Everything was top quality and service was great!

Kristin kioko

There is a reason that the line is so long! LOVE the soft serve! The wait is insignificant compared to the amazing yumminess. The face-lift is wonderful too. Bring your friends and hang out for awhile! You won't regret it.

Angela Barrett

Great ice cream. Seating is limited and not a lot of places to seat as it fills up quickly. Decent prices. Spent $26 for a family of 6

Christopher Gardner

Stellar place, not great if you're on a diet but the price to ice cream ratio is ridiculously nice. I got no clue as to how they turn a profit.

Janet Dowdy

Do NOT get a medium or large cone. Dont have a photo but it was huge! Too much for one person and very messy. Very good service and choice. Just wish they would have warned me how big the mediums were.

Kevin Gratzer

Great selection and Wow with the portions. Excellent!
Will need to go back again soon.

Add Review

Cleanliness
Comfort
Staff
Facilities
Your Score
Click here or drop files to upload