Boxcar Barney's

Unique and delicious flavors paired with large portions! A perfect place for a quick ice cream dessert.

very good prices, HUGE portions, cute atmosphere. if you get anything salted, beware. they REALLY do salt it 😳 the smell of the garbage can was annoying.

Delicious ice cream place close to Chautauqua Institution. Highly recommend the Heavenly Hazelnut and Salted Caramel flavors! Soooo tasty!

Baby cones are huge. Love coming with the family and splitting a flight. Friendly staff and yummy flavors. My favorite is cookie dough.

You have to stop here for ice cream if not to have one just to see what a large looks like. They are gigantic! I wonder how they make any money. All fresh and delicious ice cream. A summer favorite.

The place has good ice cream and shakes!

We had the worst possible service ever. When a customer asks questions politiely and is then cussed at, that is completely unacceptable behavior. We were the only customers there and needed clarification due to allergies. As a result of that behavior, we told other families not to visit. We are in the area every summer and will not spend our money at a place where workers swear at the customers. Totally unacceptable.

They give more ice cream than anyplace I’ve ever seen.

Its the best. Portions are large, taste is great, employees are polite and friendly. If you're in Mayville you must stop.

Wowza, so yummy and very ample portions. We'll be back!!