Boxcar Barney's

You get a lot of ice cream for a really cheap price and it's homemade and super delicious we go there almost every other weekend

Omg the best. I ordered rassbery ice cream thank goodness i ordered medium it was HUGE I was not expecting it. Would so go back again. Staff friendly helpful too

Rarely do I look at a serving size and think it is enough. So I got three scoops here. My first thought was wow thats too much!!! Delicious!

OMG! The variety of flavors this place has! Absolutely amazing! And the quality of the homemade ice cream? Delicious and wonderful! Just be warned, the serving sizes are huge, so if you are unsure of how much ice cream you'd like, go smaller. If you want ice cream by Chautauqua lake, this is DEFINITELY the place to go!!!

Large portions of Hershey's Hard ice cream and lots of mix ins and toppings to choose from. Waffle cone was a bit stale and hard, but otherwise a perfect summer treat.

The perfect summer stop if you are in Mayville. Yes, the line will be long but the service is very efficient. The ice cream is unbelievable good. My daughter and niece ordered a small and medium cone.

Worth the wait (there is often a line). Probably the best Ice Cream I’ve ever had. Worth a detour.

Stopped by on our drive around Chautauqua Lake for a milk shake. While service was excellent the shakes really lacked flavor! Next time we'll stop elsewhere and hopefully be able to taste the peanut butter and raspberry in our ice cream.

Great ice cream, generous portions, great service, very friendly people, frozen yogurt, chocolate & vanilla&cherrydoft serve. Lots of hard serve flavors. Nice sandwich selection. Plenty of parking. Line moves quickly. Take credit cards. (October, 2018)

Went today 7/20/2019 again. Line moved quickly. Still great soft serve. Portions still generous. Still my favorite ice cream place in the area.

The size of the portions of their ice cream is huge! Priced very reasonably as well. The lines can get long during peak times so plan accordingly and cut the staff some slack as they're working as hard as they can inside a small area to satisfy everyone's needs.