The Gelato Fiasco

The best Gelato!! So many great flavor choices. My favorite place to get Gelato.

Gelato Fiasco has really gone down hill. Very disappointing experience. Unfriendly staff and forgettable gelato. My medium 2 scoop order didn’t even get to 3/4 full. Overpriced and underwhelming. Go down the road to Fielder’s Choice, you will get a much better product for far less cost!!

Wonderful selection and great service. The seating area can sometimes get busy but the entire place feels trendy and warm. You will notice local artists have items on display as well. A great place to stop for dessert and wind down. So happy we have this little cafe in Brunswick.

Not only was the gelato amazing, but the employees were too. The very friendly young man with blonde hair made all my dreams come true. He said I could have as many flavors as I wanted in my waffle cone. I picked three and let him pick the fourth, and he picked a superb flavor AND gave me extra crunchies for on top. Across five of us I tried 10 flavors and the one I didn't love was only because of my personal preference, but not because it wasn't actually good. I would marry the gelato man but my wife said she would challenge him to a duel. So instead I'm writing this review in hopes that all of you can go meet him and have your dreams fulfilled too.

Recommended by helpful women at Goin Postal up the street. Thanks for the recommendation, we were not dissapointed. The gelato was scrumptious. Freshly made daily with quality ingredients. A must try for a refreshing treat while in Brunswick.

I'm not a huge ice cream person, but the amazing flavors and perfect texture of this gelato keeps me coming back for more all year round. The staff is very friendly and you can try as many of the flavors as you would like before buying. I don't drink coffee but the people around me always say it's really good.

Amazing staff! They make an effort to get you exactly what you want. Even had a worker tell me about a time where they gave someone 40 flavors in a dish 😆 I’ve been coming here for years because of the delicious and unique flavors and fun staff. I even went to Italy in April and was surprised to find that the gelato at Gelato Fiasco is more delicious and more creative than anywhere I experienced in Italy. Truly authentic, delicious gelato. You have to try it!

Everyone is friendly and quick to serve you or give you samples. Portions are generous. You can get more than one flavor in one dish and every flavor I've tried is delicious. Atmosphere is nice and facilities are always clean. Open late, which is a huge plus.

The best gelato ever! So creamy and flavorful not to mention the inside of the business is just beautiful. The staff was so friendly and helpful not to mention the product was phenomenal!
DEF recommend 100%

Love this place! I can try any flavors I want! I get the SMALLEST size and they put so much gelato in it I still can't finish my bowl! AND YOU CAN MIX FLAVORS. My favorite is their raspberry (trifle?) And ANY of their chocolate flavors together!