The Gelato Fiasco

Fantastic gelato, selection, and people. The fruit flavors (especially mango) are what I tend to go for; however, the coffee and chocolate flavors are also amazing. Best thing is you can sample anything before you decide. I have been to a few of there locations and they are good - this one is great. Check it out if you haven't, bring your guests if you have!

July 1, 2022
Gelato Fiasco catered our Welcome Dinner Dessert for our son's wedding weekend, July 1, 2022. It was a perfect dessert for a hot Summer night in July. So delicious, smooth and cool.
We had a great experience working with Mitch Newlin at Gelato Fiasco, based in Brunswick and Portland, Maine. He is lightning fast at responding and thoroughly answers all questions.
The gelato is made from scratch, with hundreds of flavors to choose from. You can taste test many of their flavors. They can accommodate different food restrictions, you can even make your own flavor. We renamed one of their flavors for our bride and groom.
The presentation was very attractive and the server was well dressed and very professional.
The price was very fair, serving size perfect(you could always go back for more-and we did).
Gelato Fiasco supplies everything; dishes, spoons, napkins.
They set up, take down and even box up and leave the left overs.(if any)
I would highly recommend Gelato Fiasco.
Terri and Nathan Emerson
July 2022

OMG...amazing gelato and wild yummy flavors! Super friendly staff and the Treat Cup is just the right size, even after a big meal.

I work at Hatch Home on Maine Street in Brunswick, right up the street from Gelato Fiasco. I visited briefly this afternoon and Jeff, who brought me a coffee, served me two samples of gelato and was as friendly and welcoming as a salesperson could be!!! Way to go, Jeff! We need more people like you in the world. I’ll definitely be back & happy to recommend you! Great job!!!

Always great customer service here! The gelato is pretty great too 😉

THE HYPE IS REAL!! Definitely worth the try as the gelato is DELICIOUS and they have a huge variety of flavors. Try to go sooner in the day because they run out of flavors pretty fast. LOVE their special recycling bin for the red spoons and the cups.

So friendly and helpful workers here! Rotating seasonal flavors keep things fresh. Very generous portions.

I have not been to the store, but I have purchased their gelato by the pint in my grocery store in Tennessee. The first pint I got was not smooth like gelato should be, so I contacted them via the website. They mailed me a coupon for a free pint. They said they made some improvements in their shipping procedures. The second pint was much better. I have since purchased a third pint of dark chocolate caramel sea-salt and it is exquisite. All three of the flavors come through so vividly. I have been a Talenti customer for quite a while, but I might start buying Gelato Fiasco more frequently. It is usually cheaper, and I appreciate that it is still as small locally-owned company, they're not local to me. Talenti has been bought out by Unilever.

I really enjoyed the gelato here, it was delicious! There's so many different flavors that you could go here anytime and try a flavor you've never had before! The customer service is great, and the employees always treat my family and I with respect. Will 100% come back again to try more flavors.

Better than the best gelato I could find in Italy.