Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe

Food was fine, guy that took my order had an attitude. Apparently it's offensive when asked what type of bagel you want to say "regular", instead of "plain." As if regular would mean anything other than plain. I suggest a lesson in common sense and manners for the little man behind the counter.

Customer service was excellent. Coffee and bagels delicious at a very good price.

Best bagels and sandwiches in the keys. Stop for coffee, breakfast lunch. You will not be dissatisfied or left hungry. Great friends great people. Check them out today!

This place is a joke. I called to place an order for 5 subs. Everyone wants something different. So the lady said she would have to call me back in 5 mins to get my order. I have never called a restaurant/ “sandwich shop” and they told me they would call me back to get my order. I couldn’t help but to laugh 😂 Well never got a call back.

Excellent food and good prices. If you are on big pine, must visit.

Wonderful coffee and bagels, at great prices. The breakfast blend is incredibly smooth even black.

Fresh and soooo good

AFFORDABLE AND DELICIOUS! One of the best places to go to eat in the keys :)

Best bagels in the keys, but the service is ABSOLUTELY HORRIBLE!! Even the manager/owner is rude! Such a shame you will be loosing business because its so hard for the staff there to be friendly!

LOVE this place!!
Great food, clean little place, outstanding customer service best describe this place. They should be open 7 days a week so better serve their customers.