Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe

Best bagels ever! Wien going back from Key West we’ll definitely stop to buy bagels again

Great prices even in a tourist area, staff is helpful and extremely kind. Highly recommend trying the Guava and Cheese Pastry, as well as the Vanilla Bean coffee flavoring. Bagels and homemade cream cheese are so good! ♡ Loved our, much needed, visit in the middle of our camping trip.

Food was good, the coffee was OK, by 11 am already not too hot and scarce. This place is clean, and the staff is good.

Food was great, friendly staff, A+ coffee, clean and quick service

Fresh bagels and coffee . I had the bagel suage egg and cheese bagel with the hazelnut coffee . Delish!!my daughter and brother had the vanilla shake . Best shake ever!!

We love this place for a quick bite to eat. Located in a hidden corner in the Big Pine Key Winn Dixie Shopping Plaza, the bagels are freshly made an can be loaded with a seemingly endless list of goodies. We like the breakfast options best. Huge menu for a small place. It can be busy and the seating is limited.

Our first time visiting the Keys and we had a wonderful time! We were searching for a good casual place for coffee and breakfast - we were really craving bagels! Found this place online and decided to head on over. Relaxed and welcoming atmosphere, delicious flavors of coffees, and warm and fresh bagels with several flavors of cream cheese! It seemed to be a busy place, with people greeting each other like old friends, chatting with the owner and ordering their "regular breakfast". So glad we found this little yet enjoyable Bagel Shoppe, we will be back!

My favorite breakfast and lunch spot!! Always very friendly and efficient. Very clean and comfortable in there small dining area. The food is fresh and they only serve quality products. Oh yeah and the best coffee in town, I try and go every morning for some. Great prices great service and great food are hard to find these days!!

Just moved to the area. I was very happy to find this place and it actually be good! Clean inside with a great menu of breakfast and lunch. Iced chai latte is delicious. Prices are very reasonable and staff was timely and friendly. You can even buy day old bagels (bags) for $2.50. This will for sure be a place my husband and I eat at weekly.

We are visiting from Cleveland, OH where we are spoiled with great bagels so we have high standards! This bagel shop on Big Pine Key was delicious! We had an everything bagel (mish mosh), homemade chicken salad sandwich on sesame, bacon egg and cheese bagel sandwich and a mango smoothie. Thumbs up on all and the owner was really friendly. We highly recommend.