Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe

We love this place! Best grilled blueberry muffin my wife and I have ever tasted, and such a nice staff. We used to frequent Big Pine Key from Orlando, but have since moved away from Florida. Haven’t been in years, but we hope they are still around and kickin when we return.

Small bagel and coffee shop. Excellent service and creative menu. We even saw a key deer outside the window. Bagels are fresh and lots of interesting sandwiches. I liked my sandwich, bagel with lots of good veggies. Nice place to stop for lunch when shopping at Winn Dixie, at same shopping center.

If you're going for the bagels, they are obviously made from scratch and DELICIOUS! Lots of cream cheese and super fluffy! However I was not a fan of the staff, make me feel rushed and nervous when ordering and was no help. Unless you can pay in cash you have to spend 10 dollars to pay with card which really wouldn't be much of a problem. They also serve other made from scratch breakfast foods which I did not try but looked very good! Overall, food was really good but staff was a disappointment.

Stopped in to grab lunch to take to the beach. We had awesome friendly service and excellent food!! Definitly reccomend.

Excellent food created by excellent people!

Great sandwiches and good prices. I stopped here on my way to visit the blue hole.

Nice little bagel shop in a mall. Bagel was very decent as was the bacon, egg and cheese on it. Excellent coffee along with a friendly staff and customers! Small place with a few tables plus takeout. Plenty of parking. I have not tried the lunch sandwiches but the menu sounds good.

Bagels are poor, small and tasteless. Tried a cinnamon raisin and a blueberry. Sandwiches were fair but for 8 bucks they were very light on meat. Very slow, 20 min wait for a sandwich and the gentleman who helped us was very stressed out. Hoped for more. Not impressed.

Love love love their bagels!! Their lox bagel is fabulous and I am not the biggest fan of smoked salmon. Definitely a place to grab some good food if you want a nice lunch or breakfast.

The staff was very friendly. I got the Cafe con Leche and a bacon, egg, and cheese on a bagel. Both were well made and I will definitely be back here again when I'm in the area.