Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe

Delicious food and great service! Highly recommend giving this place a try.

Amazing bagels, Great flavors and best of all amazing kind and friendly service. Reminds me of when I lived in New York, Reminiscing on; Waking up early on the weekends for a hot bagel. Definitely my stop before heading out to the reef!

The best grilled Reuben sandwich I ever had. My wife has tried bagels all over God's green earth and said it was the best cinnamon raisin bagel she ever had. Excellent service, great food.

First time here, bagels and burger were delicious. Coffee and smoothie were also good. My husband said he was going to dream about the shaved ribeye sub 😂😂 so we’ll definitely be back!

While driving to Key West we were getting some pictures of the Key Deer in the area. Found Bagel Island by accident and decided to try it. Very good food and service.

Easy strong four or more. Wow! Who knew? What a wonderful gem of a spot tucked in the corner of the plaza. Delicious fresh baked bagels, pretty good coffee, friendly and helpful; all at a very good value. Love those prices.

Damn, I wish I knew of them sooner. Lots of interesting offerings for lunch beckoning me back.

Worst breakfast ever. I go out breakfast a lot but never had such a poor and sad plate with two eggs, 3 see through and dry pieces of "bacon" and for hash browns, I had a Winn-Dixie pattie. I was left with hunger after that and I will NOT recommend this if you want a real money worth breakfast plate. My husband said bagel was ok. Mine was served in a paper plate.

Best breakfast or lunch in the entire FL keys. Don't miss it!

Great little cafe, open early at 7AM most mornings. The staff was very friendly which was great. Prices, in my opinion, are really good for breakfast and coffee options and then pretty typical for lunch options. Regardless, the food and drink were great quality, and I would recommend for either breakfast or lunch. *Note: the shop prefers to use cash under $10 if possible, so think ahead. They won't deny your sale if you don't have cash, but it's always nice to support local businesses through little things like using cash for small purchases.

Small but food was good. The owners very nice and personable with all their customers. Definitely will go back.