Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe
Amenities
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
- Wheelchair-accessible seating
- Takeaway
- Dine-in
Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe Reviews - 100
4.5
Quality
5.0
Location
5.0
Price
4.0
Service
4.5
Nancy Skinner
Excellent service great food and fresh bagels every time. Went here 3 mornings in a row while in the Keys on vacation. Even at 12 noon bagels taste like they’re fresh out of oven. Thank you!
Bonnie Fortin
The BEST bagels and croissants ever. The service is a little slow, but WELL worth the wait. The Beef Bomber is amazing, all the specialty cream cheeses are also very tasty....Keep them coming.....
Stephanie Ventura
This will be our new spot. Hands down best bagel I have ever had. Super friendly owners and very affordable prices!
Neil Compton
Great spot with a few outdoor tables for a quick bite to eat and coffee. Folks working are super friendly. Food came out pretty quick
JesusLovesYou Inc.
I think this place just ruined every other Rueben I will ever eat. It was made to perfection. I'll have to get another one before we head home. God Bless...
Bob Najduk
Legit NY bagel spot! Great customer service with a personal touch. Must do if you are in Marathon and need breakfast!
Michael Logan
Always friendly and great service definitely a morning stop for locals and vacationing guest it's convenient and delicious
Rachel M.
Intent to discharge. I clearly asked for half dozen price 2 with cheese. Got a hard look when I asked 4 my own receipt because she didn't want me 2 checkthat she overcharged ringing cost per bagel vs half dozen w cheese
Michelle Brownlee
Good food, fresh bagels, and friendly owners!
Tom S
Epic failure...I went here on 3/18/2018..... I got there along with a few gentlemen who were waiting as it opened. There was a girl, and the owner there. I got a coffee, and everything bagel with cream cheese... I added cream and milk (yes both) to my coffee from the jugs on the coffee counter... when I took a gulp- YEUK- I could taste something foul... I told the owner who grabbed the milk jug saying it must be bad... Thats all he said, so I asked for another cup poured a new coffee- used only cream from the other jug, and AGAIN- BAD.... I dumped it out... wasnt getting anything else. I can understand this from one perspective but to not check after I said...was not good, but to not say 'Sorry', and offer me another cup (I had to ask) was so poor... then to have it happen again... and owner said not a word to me.... BTW, the bagel was very good.... its the other that makes me say- NO WAY will I ever go back...