Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe

10 dollar sandwich with lots of fresh meats and friendly service.
The place is small but inviting. They bake their own breads every morning. The shop is located next to the Winn Dixie.
Bagel Island has a large menu with plenty of options to satisfy even the most picky eaters. Enjoy and tell them George ALVAREZZO sent you 🤙🏽

It was absolutely amazing. Fresh, delicious and fast. Service is impeccable - such a nice people. We found it by chance, but it exceeded our expectation! 🤩 P.S. The peach smoothie was more than delicious, one of the best I have ever had. 🍑

Great food, friendly environment, wonderful people working there, and lovely rooster.

Hate to give this place this score since I had researched it and saved it for a visit before we even got here. But...the bagels were awful. No flavor. Ordered several kinds, so it wasn't just one choice or flavor.

We ordered a Cuban sandwich, but we got a sandwich made with salami and American cheese, and no pickles. You're 120 miles from Cuba. How could you mess that sandwich up so badly? For the record: It's ham, turkey, pork, Swiss, mustard and pickles on Cuban bread.

Anyway, that's my honest review. I won't be back, and you shouldn't go either if you want a good bagel or a good Cuban sandwich. (Didn't eat anything else here.)

The family and I went here for breakfast. We didn’t have much time so we needed to be quick. We ordered all types of different things. Several bagels, a cinnamon roll, bacon and egg on toast, vanilla latte, frozen vanilla frappe, and a regular coffee.

Overall, the food was decent, enough to hold you over until lunch, but it’s nothing special. The inside is small and has barely enough seating. The menu is varied, which is nice. They also serve lunch. The staff was friendly. It’s a good spot to go if you need a basic breakfast to get you through a few hours.

The folks in this place are not the friendliest, but we love this restaurant's bagels. We have tried almost all of the bagel flavors. They are all delicious!

Love this small sandwich shop. Super friendly service and coffee was great the omelette was top notch! Would definitely recommend.

Awesome little hidden gem! Excellent food and service! Everything was delicious!

Absolutely delicious sandwiches. Bagel sandwich was excellent and my hubby's sandwich came on a roll that was so fresh and soft.

bagel island big pine key is the best breakfast on the island! Clean, tasty, and very reasonably priced! Highly recommended spasticity the Lox sandwich