The Mill

Always come up to Old Forge and we haven’t went to the mill in a very long time but this past winter we decided to give it a try. Very good! But if they are busy expect to wait! Other than that the food was great I just don’t recommend the shepherds pie, but everything else was wonderful. We even went two times in one week.

The veiws are incredible, the atmosphere is inviting, the staff are amazing, and the food is awesome. Wednesday and Saturdays is Prime Rib Night and it is awesome. I have pretty much had everything on the menu and have not had a bad experience yet.

Amazing presentation! Great flavor! Beautiful location! This was the place we would come to have dinner on our family vacation 20 years ago!! Happy to see be back here!

Knowledgeable bartender and inclusive menu for vegans, vegetarians with fresh homemade desserts. Perfectly broiled. Legit mashed potatoes super good

Happened upon this restaurant on our way out of town. The atmosphere was so pretty. The food was good as well. Just know before going in that it is a little more high priced than you would expect and the food options are a little fancier than I expected.

All food was excellent. Potato skins were unique and good, not a big beer selection but the ones they do have are great. Mill wick sandwich and fish fry were perfect. Wish they were more generous with the fries.

Cool place, great food. The deep fried deviled eggs were great and the Nashville hot chicken sandwich was fantastic.

Me and my wife came in, seated at 4:30pm and received food at 6:00pm. Within an hour and a half was checked on by our waitress not once! A different waitress took our drink orders, a male waiter brought our food! Then our original waitress came back upon request to the male waiter because we were asking where our waitress was because I ordered the hamburger medium and was beyond well and overcooked! My wife ordered the Nashville hot chicken sandwich, I don't like chicken but when she had me try it it was very dry, overcooked and very crunchy by far... overcooked! Never received refills for our lemon waters. The Best part was the French fries are to die for perfect!!!!! The atmosphere here between the employees was strange. A+ to the man waitress who was seen going table to table taking care of tables that were not his responsibility! We were not charged for our meal due to all the unfortunate events here but decided to go elsewhere to eat.

The fish fry tasted awesome and such a big piece. Our server took care of everything we wanted. Glad we stopped.

One of only a few open for dinner Sheppards Pie disappointing Tuna appetizers was average