Stagecoach Coffee

The coffee is fantastic as well as the food. I love the atmosphere. This is a true coffee shop and I will stop in everytime I'm in the cooperstown area. If your looking for a good cup of coffee and a bite to eat Stagecoach should be your stop!

Usually pretty decent. When there's a lot of customers, the service goes down; way down. I didnt even order a bagel, I paid for a croissant ( which costs extra). My question is, after burning the bagel, why did they continue to make my sandwch? Why not get a new bagel and then make the sandwich? I'm sure not one of the workers would eat this thing. It tasted gross. The flavor of the burnt bread was all over every component of my sandwich. I'm disappointed in this place. Stagecoach was one of my favorite places in Cooperstown.

Not sure when they expanded but it looks fantastic! Our orders were accurate. Bright, cheery and clean place to grab coffee, tea and related beverages, along with standard hot breakfast sandwiches and other goodies.

An establishment with “Coffee” in its name should know how to make an espresso. The breakfast sandwich, however, was very good and the staff is friendly and helpful. 1 for the coffee, 5 for the rest.

Nice place to grab lunch. I used to frequent them often and have not been back in awhile. I was sad to see that most of the fun coffee drinks were gone. Menu has definitely been pared down. It was still good, just not the experience that I'm used to getting when it was smaller.

Awesome coffee. I was in Cooperstown umpiring a game at double day. I stop at the coffee shop it was a bit busy. But it was great the wait. Got me a Red eye and it was great. Gracias

Coffee au last was weak, lacking robust flavor. Bagley was okay for someone spoiled by NYC bagels, but vegetable cream cheese tasted a bit off. My companion ordered oatmeal, only to be told they had "run out."

My favorite coffee place. A must visit whenever I'm in town.

Consistently unpleasant. Good food once you get it, but the ordering process is tedious and the app has pricing issues. The online ordering app does not reflect the in store policies and availability. The staff is unwilling to work around the issues and is unpleasant. The first morning my wife and I paid for items we didn’t order, and were asked to pay additionally for the items we did order. The second morning we paid for an entire breakfast order, received a call saying breakfast ended 10 mins ago and that there was no way we could get breakfast, and the only way to get a refund was to drive in and do it in person. It’s too bad, bc the food is so good, but definitely not worth the hassle.

Coffee was very good when our order was made correctly. Service from inexperienced wait staff was a little frustrating- lots of servers, only one seemed on top of things