Stagecoach Coffee

Staff was extremely overwhelmed for the amount of business being done. Orders were placed then told after waiting for them that they no longer had those items. Had to cancel my order because the wait was 20+ minutes after waiting 20 minutes to get to the counter. Coffee was good, canceling our food order was not.

Lots of space, warm, great bagels, breakfast, salad, pastries, tea, and coffee selection. Free WiFi, outlets, and clean bathrooms available.

This is an awesome coffee spot in town. The coffee options are expansive and delicious. It can get pretty busy but the staff is super nice and helpful. I ordered the house blend and it was so smooth. Also, the breakfast is so tasty! I ordered "The Unusual" which is a bagel with cream cheese, tomato, and avocado. The avocado is actually a spread or more similar to guacamole but was still very good. The bagel was flavorful and not chewy or too doughy. The lunch options were very appealing and the sandwiches looked delicious (brother said it was an excellent sandwich)

I have been to many coffee shops throughout the country and all I can say in one word is WOW!!!

The food and coffee were delicious. And the deck out back is lovely. Good service too!

Stopped in for a latte and salad, latte came quickly but was very disappointing for an in-house roast and I waited 15 minutes for a salad in a very dirty dining room. Baristas seem inexperienced and not at all concerned with restaurant cleanliness and the overall atmosphere is worn out and run down. I will say the curry chicken salad was very good though. I do not plan on stopping in again as all my experiences there have been fairly similar.

Amazing food, coffee, and people! Check it out if you are in Cooperstown! Try the Unusual. You will be impressed. Actually all the food is impressive. Lots of vegan and vegetarian choices for us!!

Food and coffee were very tasty. Nice spot for a quick lunch and had enough seating so you could still socially distance if desired. The only reason for 3 stars was because the staff doesn’t seem to upkeep the cleanliness. When my husband and I found a table we can to clean it ourselves along with the chairs as there were many crumbs one it. I also noticed that there were many tables that had chips, more crumbs, and other small trash items underneath too. I would t label the place as “disgusting” but I also wasn’t crazy about eating in a messy area. They just needed a staff member to occasionally check the dining areas and tidy up throughout the day.

Cute little cafe.
Good for coffee, tea, breakfast & lunch fare.

Keep in mind that their kitchen closes for the day sometimes hours before actual closing time and you can only order drinks.

I have to disagree with the people who had issues with the app. I use the app pretty much 4 to 5 days out of the week to order for pickup. I generally get a caramel macchiato and a plain bagel with butter. I am never disappointed. Sometimes the bagel does have a lot of butter though.