Stagecoach Coffee

My girlfriend and I went here for coffee this morning. Our drinks were delicious; definitely worth the 15 minute wait 😂! My girlfriend and I ordered: the skinny divinity, and cafe latte with pumpkin syrup. We went here yesterday as well and were not disappointed. We will be in Cooperstown one more day and plan on visiting one more time. Though the there was a long line, and a 15 minute wait, it is definitely worth the time and money!! I highly recommend going to Stagecoach.

Nice little coffee spot with great service and a lively atmosphere. Great food and decent coffee. My wife loved the curry chicken sandwich. I had a bagel with cream cheese, avocado, tomatoes, and topped with pepper. Coffee was pretty good, but nothing to write home about. Though I drink it black, so not sure about the specialty drinks!

Staff is very friendly even as a tourist they were friendly and attentive. Food is very good quality with fresh breads and cookies. Sandwiches are excellent and full of taste. Menu is imaginative and prices are reasonable. Plenty of in house seating and nice deck that is quiet. Quick wifi and easy/Starbucks vernacular to make ordering your coffee a breeze.

Cooperstown staple. Delicious coffee and food but bear warning you will WAIT for food if it’s busy. Just the nature of the business. Be patient.

Lots of baked goods, single origin coffee beans to take home, and a large drinks menu. Macaroons were good! No seating due to covid since it would be difficult to social distance. Outdoor seating available when it's not covered in snow. Friendly staff! Several milk alternative options including oat milk.

Very clean, nice atmosphere. Pastries were extremely tasty, coffee was just okay. Would recommend the baklava.

Ordered 2 BLT sandwiches, one with Gluten-Free bread, got both sandwiches with regular bread. The BLT that was SUPPOSED to be gluten free was for someone who is highly allergic to gluten. Called down and was told the girl who made them was new and in training. I get that, but when it comes to some ones health and/or safety, special precautions need to be taken.

Have been here many times as I grew up in the area. Today I came in and had Ben take my order! He gave us many good recommendations, was very friendly, service with a smile. He’s gotta be the nicest guy in the whole place, couldn’t ask for better service or better coffee!

Would have loved to stop by after late lunch, but closed at 430pm.
Update: since response received from owner, review updated to 5 stars.

It was great! This was only half of my bagel. Staff was very friendly