Evening Star Coffee Roasters- Coffee Service & Coffee Roastery

Since the COVID pandemic started I've made a concerted effort to support local small business as much as possible, so I was super excited when I learned Evening Star (right down the road from me) did Retail sales!!!
I'm a flavored coffee lover and their selection is vast! I've been ordering from them for almost a year now and while I have one constantly favorite (oh that Italian Macaroon ❤️) I try other flavors with every order & have never been disappointed. And the price is fantastic!!!
I cannot say enough good things about not only their product, but their customer service. The fact that I get to support a local business is icing on the cake (or maybe an indulgent dollop of whipped cream on my coffee😉).

Thank you Jody & Team for bringing happiness to my mornings ☀️

I have been drinking Evening Star coffee for a few years now (there’s always a bag of Jamaican Me Happy in my kitchen). Every blend and every flavor are phenomenal. And the owner, Jody, is a wonderful person. Do yourself a favor and order a bag or two! You will be hooked for life

Discovered Evening Star Coffee Roasters on one of our many trips into Pultneyville. Instantly fell in LOVE with the Banana-Bread flavor. Hands down, my favorite coffee. I like it so much I ordered a larger bag of it from their online store. Upon arrival, I was pleasantly surprised to see a free bag of coffee added to my order. Amazing! Thank you Jody and the team at Evening Star!

I cannot rave enough about this coffee! I was not a big coffee drinker until I had this! “Jamaican Me Happy” is a must, and absolute favorite! Amazing customer service as well! Highly recommend!

Evening Star Coffee is the best coffee I have ever had! I have known Jody for years and see him or his family regularly in my line of work. Very knowledgeable, always friendly, really great people.
With their huge selection of coffee flavors and varieties, you are set all year. If looking for a great gift, get them some locally roasted coffee, they will love it!

I was gifted a bag of Peru dark roast by the" Coffee Man", totally better than the Candy Man. It really made my day. It is deelish smoth no bitter or aciduc after taste. How did you kniw I drink Dark Roasr? Excellent coffee. Thanks again

We have really enjoyed discovering Evening Star Roasters and have started buying all our flavored coffees from them exclusively. The quality is very good and prices are reasonable. In our experience orders are filled quickly, and readily available for convenient pickup. We have met Jody, the owner, who is knowledgeable and a very friendly person.

Evening Star's flavored coffees are phenomenal! Italian Macaroon is my all time favorite. i've been ordering online as it's hard to find places that carry the Evening Star coffee (Leo's no longer has it). A bonus to ordering online is that they will throw in another bag of coffee sometimes one you've already chosen or sometimes a new flavor to try (I love that!).

I found this gem when visiting a bakery in Geneseo while on vacation. They served Evening Star Coffee. I found their website and have been a happy customer since then. I have tried several of their coffees, and have enjoyed all. Their descriptions are very accurate. Our favorite is Dark Knight.

I have one indulgence and it's a good cup of coffee in the morning. Forget Starbucks, Green Mountain, Dunkin Donuts. Evening Star provides quality coffee with such a wide range of flavors and intensity it would be difficult for anyone not to find one they enjoy. And, this is huge, you can get an actual pound of coffee, not 10 or 12 oz. Service is excellent. I live in Syracuse NY and received my coffee within 2 days. The aroma was heaven. My favorite is their signature blend but give others a try. You won't be sorry if you enjoy a really good cup of coffee.