Old New York Deli & Bakery Co.

Love this place the food is great, service is friendly, and they are really quick most of the time which is great in the morning! Bagels are some of the best I've ever had. Can't go wrong.

The young woman who takes orders is quite rude and almost yells at you to hurry up and order. Everyone seems othered when you ask them a question. Food is 4/10

As others have noted, not much else that is quick and easy on the way to the lifts. But worth the stop. My double cappuccino was perfect (trust me it is very rare for a place to get the milk/foam ratio correct). Had an everything egg bagel sandwich... Egg was over hard so I would've asked for it over easy had I known they didn't scramble. But the best part of the bagel was that the "everything" was in both halves! Makes such a difference. Wife had the hummus delight bagel sandwich and really enjoyed it. Daughter had the California omelette and I think they put an entire avocado on it... Yum! Coming back tomorrow!

The ABSOLUTE worst deli I have ever eaten at!

Food was bland, potato salad was overly salty, corned beef was extremely chewy and dry and the pastrami, while flavorful, was super fatty.

Rye bread was the only good part of the meal that was well executed and tasty.

Another diner ordered a salad and immediately returned it for tasting like it was made two days ago.

Truly sad considering I've never had a bad experience at a deli, until now, and I eat at them often.

Been coming here for years, but since they're letting online orders take over I can't recommend it anymore. Go in for a simple bagel and cream cheese when there's no physical line and it takes 20 minutes to receive it due to a massive line of online orders. Sad they won't prioritize customers standing outside in the cold over customers too lazy to come in.

Came across this cafe after a hike and didn't have any expectations. I walked in and immediately felt comfortable and was excited with the selection. Staff was friendly and helpful. Also, the establishment was clean and in a nice open location. If you're in the area, stop by for a treat.

One of the worst places ive ever eaten in mammoth. Workers are rude and communication is HORRIBLE. 1st off dont even bother trying to "customize" an order because they are gonna make it however they want, i tried to get my sandwhich on a bagel and add avacado but that didnt happen she completley ignored me. While ordering, the lady helping us took a personal phone call which only lasted a brief minute but still she saw we were irritated and didnt care she was just laughing away and didnt remeber where she left off with us.

The avacado bacon cheeseburger was good but the turkey sandwich and chicken noodle soup was HORRIBLE. Extremely bland and a huge let down. Very very pricey and wait times are ridiculous. Take yourself to schats bakery for a good sandwich and soup. Save yourself the let down.

$40 and a 40+ minute wait for a bagel and an omlette. Bagel was burnt crispy, tiny amount of lox, omlette left out several key ingrediants... plenty of other optipna in the village to go to instead

We were on a tight schedule, having a medical appointment later in the day, and they lost our order. We got the drinks, but they completely forgot our food and served people ordering after us. We were able to get a refund and went to eat somewhere else. We won't go back to Old New York Deli.

One of worst sandwich ever. I ordered turkey with Gouda cheese and I’ve got only turkey and lettuce were old. Cashier didn’t get correct order. Too busy talking to other employee. Didn’t even ask what kind of condiments I want in sandwich and they were not even busy since it was around 1:30pm when I ordered. Bread was good however I wouldn’t recommend to anyone for sandwich.