Old New York Deli & Bakery Co.

Nice atmosphere, friendly servers, fast service. Our sandwiches were good, bread and deli meat were fresh and tasty. We bought the strawberry cream cheese for our bagels (which were fresh) it tasted more like frosting than cream cheese. The cookies were a little over cooked then we prefer. This place has a lot of items to choose from, I gave it 4 stars due to some of the baked goods, but everything else was good.

Hi there 🤙 Been in a rush that day but still had a chance to try their coffee. I took Mocha and was good. Not to sweet, not to dark, just good. Next time will stop there for some sweet treats. They have cinnamon rolls, topped chocolate cones, variety of breads and bagels. Fresh juices, ready to eat meals, sandwiches and more. Inside you can see a tv with all info about conditions on trails, very nice 👍 almost forgot about 96 oz of coffee box, have to try it during cold days.
See you next time.

Unique and quality offerings, convenient location and reasonable price. A surprising little gem in the heart of the mountain village.

This was the first place we had breakfast at, being across the street from our hotel, and the only place in walking distance that had breakfast early in the morning. We ended up coming back here twice, but only had a sit-down breakfast the first time.

It’s a counter-service place, not full-service, so expect to place an order, get your number and wait to hear your number.

We ordered an omelette (3 egg is standard) with bell peppers, onions, turkey sausage and cheddar. Added a latke (potato pancake) and a side of crispy bacon. It came with toast (we chose sourdough).

Everything was delicious. The omelette was perfectly done and surprisingly filling, despite being listed as a 3-egg omelette, we split this and both felt full the whole morning. The add-ins added nicely to the flavor, especially the flavorful turkey sausage. The bacon was crispy, as ordered, and delicious.

The only negatives were; the butter wasn’t applied to the toast and it was cold so we had to let it sit for a while to melt and the drink selection was odd. Fortunately they had regular Coca Cola, not my favorite but it will do.

The latke was one of the first I’ve been able to find in a restaurant, usually I have to make them at home, and it was amazing. I wanted to come back and get more but just never got the chance. It was served with sour cream and apple sauce, but we just ate it straight, the apple sauce wasn’t my favorite, but both were in side containers so they can be used or not.

A couple days later we stopped in for a quick bagel and cream cheese, the bagel was nice but I can’t really talk too much about bagels. It was a good bagel and Philly cream cheese.

While waiting for the bagel, I noticed a bagel pizza, and decided I would get one to take home the last day. So that’s exactly what I did. The morning of our drive, I stopped in and grabbed a bagel pizza and some cookies. The cookies were great too! A couple days after getting home, I threw half the bagel pizza in my air fryer and wow! It was really delicious. I was quite surprised. I knew it looked good but I wasn’t prepared for how good. I have no idea how it’s served there, because I specifically asked for it ti be kept cold so I could eat it later, but I highly recommend the bagel pepperoni pizza!

This is a good restaurant in downtown Mammoth. They have bagels, sandwiches and hot/cold beverages options. They also have decent vegetarian and vegan options as well. We ordered the potato latkes( pancakes or hashbrowns like dish) with sour cream and apple sauce with an additional serving of the jalapeño cream cheese. We also ordered the everything bagel with spinach artichoke cream cheese, sesame bagel with tofu cream cheese, ham and cheese omelette with side of country style potatoes. We also ordered freshly squeezed orange juice, espresso shot and iced caramel macchiato with almond milk. The lakes were crispy and well seasoned. The sour cream and the apple sauce were really good complements for that dish. The spinach and artichoke cream cheese had predominantly spinach taste and dish not get any artichoke flavor. The tofu cream cheese with the sesame bagel was really good. The orange juice was ok and had a slight bitterness. Overall it was a decent breakfast.

It’s a cute little deli in mammoth lakes. Must go if you are here. They have good variety of bagels, cookies, sandwiches etc. They keep making fresh batches. We had blueberry muffin with cream cheese and apricot hamantaschen, with drip coffee. Loved all of it. I recommend this place😊

We visited this restaurant at around 2pm one day to order some sandwiches to-go. We had to wait in a short line when we arrived and then placed our order for two veggie sandwiches with fries. We waited at least 30 minutes for our food. Once in the car we opened the to-go boxes and found that our food was cold. The fries had absolutely no seasoning and the vegetarian sandwich was all soggy. The only good part of the meal was the yummy tractor orangic soda.

Had a bagel here, so can’t speak to the other items. Bagel was good, reasonable price (above average maybe?), ok portion for ingredients, good taste.

Both the bagel itself in terms of crunchiness and softness, as well as the ingredients on the sandwich were good, would come again to try others.

Carry many natural and nonGMO items.
The service was quick and efficient. The place was very clean and the kitchen was well staffed and immaculate. Nice lighting and music playing created a welcoming ambiance.
Safety and cleanliness protocols were taken seriously.
Busy but customers were greeted each and everyone.

Actually, I was a little disappointed. They only have medium roast coffee. I like a dark roast. That said, the sourdough pancakes were amazing. The stuffed "Yummy" French Toast were a little over the top. Good to get if you are super hungry. Very pleasant at the tables outside (in the summer).

Pro tip: if you like dark roast like I do, you can order an Americano coffee which is made with expresso and hot water. You could even ask for an extra shot of expresso.

Pro tip 2: don't forget to buy a black and white cookie when you are there for an afternoon snack.

A little pricey, but the food was really good. They had authentic NY everything bagels and great menu choices. Probably the best spot to get breakfast before hitting the slopes in Mammoth. They get real busy so be prepared to wait 10-20 minutes.