Old New York Deli & Bakery Co.

So this place sells bagels and cream cheese but they can't price how much a bagel with cream cheese and slices of tomatoes and onions cost. Instead they told my friend to order the bagel with lox and put the lox on the side charging her $16 🙄. 1 point reduction for that. Also the pastrami sandwich was the worst i ever had. Bread was wet and falling apart immediately after receiving it. The pastrami was fatty and hard to tear up with your teeth. I don't think it's supposed to be like that. Also the fries were tasteless and they didn't provide ketchup. 2 points reduction for that menu item. We ordered here 3 times on our 4 day trip in Mammoth and each time i was disappointed with something. Overall for the cost of this place i rather pay the same amount at a regular restaurant away from the ski area.

Food was pretty good but the service just wasn’t up to par. I’d understand if it was extremely busy but there were only 4/5 people inside and hardly any outside. I waited at the register to order for almost 5min before anyone even acknowledged my girlfriend and I. Multiple employees walked past us and even made eye contact and still refused to acknowledge us. Once the young lady got to us it was very quick transaction but still no excuse for lack of service. It isn’t hard to do. I hope that this was a one off situation. I intend on giving this place another try maybe on a different day and find out.

Hard working servers. Very good prices for a ski resort. Come on time as peak hours means you will need to wait on your bagel. Everything bagel went too hard on the cumin seeds

Every time I’m snowboarding in Mammoth Lakes I stop at the Old New York for breakfast daily. Their menu is huge, food is delicious, and the service is consistently exceptional. Located at the bottom of the Village Gondola it can also be a great lunch spot if you’re skiing at Canyon Lodge.

We got 2 breakfast burritos, bagels and chive cream cheese for breakfast as well as two lattes. The lattes were very diluted with milk. The kids did not like the burritos and the cream cheese was very average. The bagels tasted OK but not exceptional. This place has a great location so it’s convenient but they need to improve the quality of their food.

Well priced decent food. The eggs aren’t great, and they don’t have real maple syrup even though they advertise it. The French toast is really good though

Great Reuben sandwich! Plus, I'm Polish and one of our national dishes is a chicken noodle soup and their version was a nice surprise!
Note: I was there in 2018 so maybe that has changed, but one thing I didn't like were single-use cutlery and plates. Be more eco-friendly guys! ;)

Got my order wrong two days in a row, despite me clarifying with the cashier both times. I know it's busy, it try listening to your customers when they are ordering. Needless to say, I won't be back again.

Visiting Mammoth Lakes and wanted to get a quick bite. Their website was not working I was unable to checkout and pay for my order. I tried to download the app but couldn't find it in the app store. So I ended up calling. After a few busy signals I got through. The person on the phone was not great at customer service after everything I said she said is that it? And she was just like ok no thank you, no have a nice day, or anything. They gave us burnt pancakes and tried to hide them underneath a not burnt one. I had a Popeye bagel that was good and fresh. We also ordered a veggie burrito which was good and very hearty. They lost points because of customer service and the burned pancake.

Came here twice during my stay in mammoth. Great selection for breakfast. Delicious bagels and coffee. Open for dine in during our stay Oct 2020. If you stay at the village this is a great spot to warm up during the colder months and grab some breakfast.