Old New York Deli & Bakery Co.

If I’m being completely honest this place is pretty average. The food isn’t outstanding but it’s okay, it’s not bad. The line however is soooooo long and it take a really long time for them to give you your food.

Stopped by to pick up 5 sandwiches for a hike. Took a half hour. Granted, they were busy when we ordered them but we saw people after us getting thier orders while we waited. I stood by the register and watch the disorder on the line. Maybe that's not normal for them but wasn't very pleased.

Place was half empty and they told me it would take 20 minutes to get an everything bagel with butter, pretty remarkable honestly.

Same thing with the Americanos, had to order iced coffee instead in 15 degree weather because they said it would take 20 minutes.

This was at 8am on a Friday, this is a breakfast spot. Not sure how they think its acceptable to not serve the main item at their deli.

Update: and of course the person behind me got a bagel within 5 minutes. This is why it's important to have competent staff at front of house. I will never come back to this place in my entire life.

Amazing choices, very tasty. Their chilaquiles is bomb

Came here in the morning to order some sandwiches for lunch later that day. The service was super friendly! The bagels looked so good I ordered an everything bagel with butter for later and was not disappointed! The sandwiches are great New York style with lots of meat! I loved the potato salad! Everything tasted super fresh. Would love to come back next time we visit the area. Thank you for the great food and service!

Don’t bother. 30 minute wait for 2 sandwiches. Dirty inside. Slowest place I’ve ever seen and expensive. It’s in the village, but still. There are much better places on Mammoth.

Great food and drinks! But Maggie needs to work on her customer service skills.

Best everything bagel I’ve ever had. Love that everything is so fresh. Fast too!

Found my new breakfast spot in mammoth! Really good breakfast burritos and bagels.

Fast friendly service. My BBQ chicken salad was great. The pastrami sandwiches were just okay, but the homemade rye bread was good. We would go again to try other items.