Herkimer Coffee

I usually get my bag coffee here and it’s been flawless and so delicious every time (been drinking their bourbon process Colombian) and their roast dates are always *very* recent which is amazing. I usually get an oat milk cortado there and it’s been good each time! Baristas are efficient and friendly and the space is really cute

Loved my latte. It wasn't too strong or too milky. It was done just right for my taste. People were friendly. I will return for another cup of coffee when I am in the area next time.

As a recent-ish transplant to the PNW, it’s been a joy to try out all of the amazing coffee of the area. That said, Herkimer did not hold up to the hype. I’ve visited this location twice, each time ordering a cappuccino and a cortado (the standard by which I measure most third wave coffee shops’ abilities: can they foam the milk skillfully, wet or dry foam, can I taste the roast of the beans, what’s the flavor profile, etc.) The first time I got a very average cappuccino with a bit more acid. Honestly, I could’ve had the same quality from Starbucks.
Knowing ats a local favorite, I have it a second chance a few days ago. Same exact “meh” experience. The staff are all friendly, but their coffees are pretty boring. Disappointing, because I always want more amazing coffee shops to visit. :-(

I’ve been here twice now (after really missing the amazing lattes my now-closed local coffee shop made with Herkimer beans). The first time I was unimpressed and thought I’d just gotten a bad drink. Today was my second time, with a different employee making the drink, and it wasn’t any better. The shots were weak, and they just don’t seem to know that oat milk MUST be shaken before using it each time, or it tastes weird. That being said, they also aren’t using a good quality oat milk, and they are charging more for it that many coffee shops charge for a superior brand. Won’t be back.

Very nice!! It was a bit chilly baddie, so I had to wear my jacket. They definitely could've turned the heat up. But the London fog I ordered was fantastic! The customer service was great, the atmosphere and seats were amazing, and the place was really clean. Great location, too.

Always consistently good coffee.
And friendly baristas. Great ambience for hanging out and conversing with friends.
But mostly, just really good coffee.

Exceptionally good coffee and friendly service.

Espresso is unbeatable, the best in Seattle by far! Great baristas, delicious pastries, and they always are playing killer music. Can’t recommend enough

Best coffee, and best coffee shop my wife and I had while in Seattle for an anniversary getaway

Love it. Friendly barista, cheap, and yummy coffee. Also like the location.