Sweet Creams Cafe

Don't let the closed front door fool you. This is, and should be, a foodie staple in the heart of East Stroudsburg's Main Street, and yes, it is OPEN.

At the time of this review, due to staffing issues, they only offer takeaway and small outdoor dining (two tables depending on the day) but do NOT let that stop you! Get there. Order at the small window to the left of the front door and thank me later.

Filled potatoes and sandwiches with a european-like twist, salads, fresh soups (we had the steak and ale chowder), delicious coffee and homemade ice cream - that has been served for literal decades. Give it a try. You will not be disappointed.

Stopped here for ice cream after a long hike. The shop was closed for inside seating but you could order from the window. The prices for ice cream were not listed and we had to ask about the type of cones. We paid $7 for two different flavors in a cup - a little pricy but the scoops were big and the ice cream was tasty. The person that took our order was nice but he seemed slightly perturbed - maybe because his help did not show up? Also, the spoons we got were flimsy and sharp on the edges. Flip it over so you don’t cut your lips!

Small little hole in the wall. Homemade ice cream and meals. Ladies seemed nice enough but despite being open 3 more hours kind of made you feel like they were in a hurry to leave. Could of just been the day. No real allergy friendly options but Almond milk

3 stars, for exceptional service. The staff was very friendly and accommodating. Large menu with a lot of variety. We ordered two sandwiches and were disappointed in the quality and taste of both. I would go back to try the homemade ice cream but probably won’t be having lunch here again. The basil lemonade was the highlight of the meal.

Homemade ice cream was delicious. This spot is so cute downtown. Must visit for a sweet treat. Will return!

On whim we decided to go Stroudsburg and a popular travel site listed Sweet Creams as a popular choice, so glad we took the advice. It’s a small homey cafe with great sandwiches and tasty soups. A great spot for lunch or to get coffee and some ice cream. Highly recommended.

We loved the original menu and throw in a great local ice cream shop. Awesomeness for sure, a must try when in the area.

Food is really good. Brownie banana spilt is huge! Place is very clean. Cool paintings on wall. Staff very nice. Parking can be a challenge. Prices are a little high.

We ordered 4-hot chocolate’s after a cold day out shopping at the outlets. The expression machine wasn’t working and they didn’t have chocolate chips. Took forever to make them. They were eh….

Amazing place! I love the food, the staff, and the ambience and the vibes. Delicious sandwiches, pizzas, drinks, coffee, and ice cream! Highly highly recommend this wonderful area.