Amenities
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Wheelchair accessible restroom
- Wheelchair accessible seating
- Curbside pickup
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Sugar Island Reviews - 100
4.8
Quality
5.0
Location
5.0
Price
4.0
Service
4.5
Dwight Rich
My Dad's 89th Birthday was February 12,2015 and he loves chocolate pie. My Brother,sister in law,wife and I planned on getting him one for his birthday. Brother lives in South Carolina couldn't come up so I was going to handle the pie delivery. I got Sick couldn't make the trip so I go online for help. Tried Bakery's in Onslow,Johnson, Pender, and New Hanover County. I could get the pie, but no delivery. Then Luck was with me, I found Sugar Island Bakery,206 N. Topsail Dr.,Surf City N. C. They baked the pie, delivered it (AT NO CHARGE) they only make large wholesale deliver's and I feel their is a charge for that. Sugar Island wouldn't take a dime for their trouble, pie was delivered on time, best dad has ever had, leaving John Rich (MY DAD) asking how did you do that? Simple answer, Sugar Island Bakery going the extra mile to help to Sons make their Dad's Birthday. THANK YOU FROM CRAIG & DWIGHT RICH. ( YES HE ATE THE WHOLE PIE)
Phyllis Ramsay
This little place has it all, great pies and treats and delicious macaroons and really nice people. When I want something truly special, this is where I go.
Stephen Koplin
The baked goods were fantastic and everyone there was very friendly. The upstairs reading area was interesting, but would be a lot better if it was decluttered
Michele Prevette
Great customer service. Friendly staff. Great variety of cookies, bars, cup cakes and pies. Everything is made with local ingredients, farm to store.
Olivia F
Two words: cheddar pigs.
I look forward to them every year. The rest of the family goes for sweet stuff which looks tasty, but cheddar pigs are my favorite.
Amanda Marsico
Fantastic food. Get there early. They often sell out of fan favorites like Jam Bars and cupcakes. And grab a book or a beer while you're there.
Sara Woodington
SO AMAZING, This will be #1 on our list from now on! Collectible books, knick knacks, kitschy gifts, but best of all the pastry ❤️
John N
Awesome everything. Delicious cookies, and the cinnamon rolls are the best anywhere. Eventually I'll try all of it. Always fresh and interesting.
Hannah Martin
Great place with delicious iced coffee and baked goods - huge fan of their cinnamon rolls & coconut macaroons!
Emily Allen
All of their bakery items are homemade and delicious. Wonderful place to buy a pastry and a coffee and read a book.