Search
3.8

100 reviews

Amenities

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Wheelchair accessible restroom
  • Wheelchair accessible seating
  • Outdoor seating
  • Delivery
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in

For Five Coffee Garden City Reviews - 100

3.8
Quality
5.0
Location
5.0
Price
4.0
Service
4.5
Joseph Fravola

Do you love coffee? Do you love decadent treats like cookies, croissants, and cake? What about gourmet breakfast and lunches? Because this is the place that You and Garden City have been dreaming of. This high end franchise has the special ingredients for the perfect cafe to fulfill all your desires! The quality of every purchase and experience is everything you've dreamed of. Stop by and welcome the newest addition to your daily routine and be part of the scene!

Thomas McDermott

I was very impressed with For Five. The atmosphere was clean and classy, the food was delicious and filling, and the coffee was incredible!

Keep in mind, you don't get waited on while you're here; you pick wherever you want to sit and you order at the register. They give you a table number and then your order is brought out to you. The line can get long to order and it can be annoying waiting in line instead of waiting at your table to order.

I've had a lot of the food items on the menu, I have yet to be disappointed with any of them. There are plenty of options ranging from steak and salads to pancakes and oatmeal.

They pride themselves on their coffee that they roast daily, and I have to say that it's definitely one of the better East Coast roasts that I've had. Hot or iced it's all delicious. Highly recommend trying some of their flavored lattes.

Megan Youmans

Been here a few times. Their coffee is good and nice ambience. Their food is definitely worth a try though. A little pricey but I have loved everything off the menu I’ve tried so far. Nice place to stop in for lunch or to get some work done with a drink.

William Kucmierowski (Brimstone)

Well rounded coffee house; but - I would've liked a larger list of fun coffee to choose from. The caramel apple cookie was delightful and the back outdoor area was breezy and pleasant. Coffee wasn't bad, we had the two specialty flavors - not what I wanted; however good nonetheless. Will definitely return.

alyssa garbarino

From someone who lives out of state and only gets to come back and visit for holidays, For Five has easily become my must-stop spot when I’m home. Their menu is absolutely delicious with so many unique and delicious options to choose from. This is the perfect spot to grab a quick lunch and coffee with friends or study for a massive exam. The ambiance is such a laid back vibe and the staff is so kind and helpful. If I went to school in the area, I definitely would be using this as a study spot because it’s also relatively quiet. All of the food that I tried was fantastic. The Loaded Salmon Sriracha Toast is the most delicious toast that has a sriracha cream cheese piled high on sourdough with salmon, egg, capers, pickled red onions, and smoked salmon. The Peach French Toast was absolutely gorgeous and I must say, tasted just as fresh and delicious as it looked. The Birria Grilled Cheese is a personal favorite that hits every single time. It’s got a little kick so be prepared, but it is packed with great flavors. The Burrata Pesto sandwich was also another crowd pleaser as the combination of pesto and burrata is just too good to pass up. If you get the chance to stop by, definitely do because I go whenever I’m home and it never disappoints!

Ari G

Calming atmosphere + delicious food! Absolutely loved the interior of the place. The staff and service was fast and efficient. Outside sitting was just as lovely as inside. Definitely recommend for a breakfast/ brunch with friends and family.

Recommendations:
Matcha macadamia lavender latte: sweet matcha w light creamy milk and strong lavender flavour
Avocado crush :super delicious avocado w onion and egg comes with side salad (dressing super good)
Overnight oats: sweet and delicious
Crossiant: fluffy and buttery

Arielle Ru

Wow I didn't expect such amazing food at a coffee shop but this place is a gem 💎. The Mediterranean bowl was so filling and the falafels were freshly made. My friend got the peach French toast which was also delicious.

It was pretty busy but the cafe is big so we found seating. There is also parking in the back. Will definitely be back!

Courtney Chase

I love the location in Manhasset so I was excited to see them open in Garden City! I ordered the peach French toast, a fruity pebble cookie and a freedo cappuccino to go. The French toast was unfortunately underwhelming, pretty small portion and nothing special presentation wise however, the coffee was awesome and the cookie was fantastic! So overall, peach French toast not recommended but still a great place and I'm glad they're closer. Will definitely be back.

Abigail Sandoval

This coffee restaurant is so cute and have many options for bakery items or coffee. I tried a dish that they also which is the Nutella pancakes but they put way too much Nutella in it and the pancakes were a bit dry. On the other hand I did try their cookies and they are really good just that each one cost $6

Nicole Schmidt

This was a 1 and done for us. 1st didn't realize it was an "upscale " panera. The lady at the register was very distracted and seemed confused with everything we ordered. I will give this place A+ for plating presentation, but they sacrifice the food for the look. My plate had so much arugula it totally overwhelmed and I removed 95% of it. The bread wasn't toasted so the tomato started to make it soggy and the taste overall was average at best. The other plate the cream cheese under the eggs just made the eggs cold and took away from the taste and the fact that the eggs and prosciutto were seperate on each side meant you either had to deconstruct to mix the 2 or you only tasted 1 at a time. It was packed with young people so I guess they are just following the fad.

Add Review

Cleanliness
Comfort
Staff
Facilities
Your Score
Click here or drop files to upload