Pie Town 'Ohana' Cafe

Best pie ever!! Not kidding, I am a huge fan of pecan pies, not the kind that have a sprinkle of pecans on top, the kind that are pecans top to bottom and this place delivers. Very friendly staff as well. Worth the trip!

Excellent food and service. I had the home made green chili stew and a side of home made pinto beans. Wife had grilled chicken, steamed veggies and baked potato. Cook accommodated my wife’s gluten free, dairy free dietary needs. Stop by. You won’t be disappointed. Waiting for our pie to be served. It looks excellent too.

We must have missed them, as we drove by I thought someone was standing in the window but only one car, the other 2 shops in Town had full parking lots, maybe the next time through I love taking RT 60 Interstates are so sterile and dangerous today nothing to see except the same truck stops.

We really enjoyed our visit to Pie Town and will most definitely be back at Ohana Pie Town asap! I had the Pinto Beans for my lunch and they were perfectly cooked!! I also had a slice of the Mango Red Chile pie. It was superb!!! Very accommodating and friendly staff!
We stopped back by the next day, as we were traveling back through and picked up 3 pies to take home. They had live music and people were dancing, hootin' & stompin'! My kind of place! Thank you, Ohana! Y'all kind folks made it a very magical experience ❤️

This is a tiny restaurant in the middle of nowhere... but is the only place to eat along about 100 miles of highway. Drink orders were handled quickly, but it took over 1/2 hour to get 3 pulled pork sandwiches with potatoes. Pie business (eat in and carry out) was brisk. We needed to get on down the road so we skipped pie. Pulled pork sandwiches and drinks was 45 dollars for 3 people.

I rearranged my road trip to be in Pie Town when this place is open and I recommend you do the same. The food is amazing, and it’s a quintessential small business in a small town. I love it so much. Seriously it’s the best breakfast I’ve ever had, probably some of the best burgers ever, and you HAVE to try the New Mexican Apple Pie.

Edit: I also bought some jam while I was there. I got a jar of the jalapeño jam not sure whether I would like it, but I wish I had stocked up! I highly recommend getting some of the extras they sell at the Café.

I have not had the opportunity to taste test 'Ohana' Cafe, yet. It was closed on my last trip to Eagar. I had stopped by to utilize the doggie park and had a lovely chat with the new owner.
After reading the reviews, I regret not planning my trip home to include a stop during business hours.
The owner is very friendly and easy to chat with. I will be visiting soon, very soon.

Great pies stopped by to get the wife something while we were on vacation , and it was amazing

Shared BBQ pork poutine (oui, poutine in NM) with hubby to save room for PIE! I had blueberry and peach and Hubs had regular apple. It was all really good. Owner even came out and chatted with us. He just bought the place last year, so ignore any bad reviews from before that. He and the waitress were both really nice. Service was prompt and prices reasonable considering the rather isolated location. Highly recommend.

Great place to stop on your travels. Try the pear and ginger pie.