Little Notch Bakery and Café

The store's pies, bread, and pastries were all displayed very nicely. However, no pricing was shown anywhere and all items were WAY OVER PRICED. We had the blueberry and apple tarts, OVER $9 EACH, tasted like a buttered croissant with smeared canned blueberries. The brownie we also had was not good nor worth $2.75. The boxed brownies at the grocery store are rated higher stars than theirs. We will NEVER buy anything there ever again and world never recommended this store to anyone.
SHOPPERS BEWARE.

Great sweet stop for the whole family. Blueberry pie a la mode was a delight and all my kids loved their waffle cone with kids sized scoops. Fun flavors & wishing I had tried the cold brew coffee float, yum!

The pizza and pastries were very tasty and definitely recommendable. Pizza is one of the best in the area and the pastries as well. However the bread I tried (a baguette) was very bad and definitely not fresh - would not recommend it.

Best pizza and bread. The number twelve pizza is a favorite.
My son and his partner buy the raisin walnut bread in surplus before they return to Brookline MA where there are some very good bakeries.

Pretty good pizza and the range of toppings is great, but the “25 minute” wait was 40 minutes. We also got garlic bread and a garden salad. Staff was a little annoyed when we asked for them to let us have the garlic bread as soon as it was ready because we had two hungry little kids, but they complied. Salad was fine, fresh and well portioned, but not something you would go out of your way for. My suggestion would be to order a pizza in if you have the time.

Had the steak sandwich and the prosciutto sandwich, both were delicious!! Also got a sticky bun and a raspberry tart for the next morning and they were also delicious! Love this bakery!! Top notch!

Delicious pastries and coffee from a cute local place. Great for breakfast, wish we would have tried their pizza!

I ordered a small artichoke, red pepper and pesto pizza ($20) and it was AMAZING. It was enough for two people to share, as a lunch or appetizer.

All I can comment on is their sticky buns. These are phenomenal. So much so we drove out of our way on the trip home just to get another.

I’ve read other reviews that complain about the price. The sticky buns were reasonably priced. But it is true they do not list their prices.

A note to the management....you could probably improve your Google reviews by simply listing the price...there’d be less surprised and upset customers.

A word to those who complained about the price....have you bought anything else on the island? Just about everything is overpriced so it’s kinda tough to know when to complain about pricing.

Final note....cool little shop, great pastry’s, weird hours, overall definitely worth a visit (or two) but ask prices first.😜

Delicious pizza! Took awhile to receive it, but worth it! The people receiving sandwiches made me wish I'd tried a sandwich too! The bathroom wasn't the cleanest. The homemade bread looked delicious. I bought a sesame loaf at $5.99 US funds, aka sticker shock! Hope it's as tasty as it looks so that I can forget the price. They don't post prices on their baked goods. Ask for the price ahead. They are taking advantage of tourists good will.