NewCity Coffee Co.

After waiting in line for 30 minutes, they closed the kitchen for food when we were next in line. I understand they need to close it at some point but it was 12:47 and they’re open until 4. They should have at least allowed the people in line that were already in the building to order. There should have been a warning that the kitchen would close after a certain amount of people so we could get out of line.

Pleasant staff. Knowledgeable about the area.
Got deserts to go. Outstanding. Hope to get back
Before our time is up.

Best place for pastries and coffee! Got strawberry tart and hot chocolate and my son was so happy(he is a picky eater). Recommend visit this place!

I drove 30 minutes for this cute little coffee shop, and I loved it. The Christmas coffee flight had 4 seasonal coffees which were absolutely amazing. They were full sized to my surprise as well so def easy to split! They’ll bring out your drinks and food to you when it’s ready as well! The staff was very nice!

It would be helpful when they serve coffee outside, to also have condiments with them instead of saying "cream and sugar is inside"...Smh!!

My kids and I had a great morning at New City. The food was delicious and was served quickly. The place was pretty busy, but still had a great vibe... didn’t feel crowded or noisy. They seemed to help each person quickly. We got the coffee flight and loved the concept. All of the flavors were delicious! We also ordered a breakfast burrito, french toast, waffle, and omelet... all delicious! I really enjoyed the toffee nut coffee from the flight so I asked for a large one to-go. They informed me that they usually only make those for the flights but that they would make an exception. I appreciated that because it was good! I definitely recommend checking out this spot. I just wish they would extend their hours.

Nice little coffee place in Lake Mary. They seem to take their coffee seriously - they have a nice Rocket espresso machine and they also serve nitro cold brew, which was as good as I have had.

Food and coffee selection are amazing, great atmosphere too. Staff is really friendly

Staff wasn’t welcoming or quick to acknowledge /greet you or take your order. The Califia oat milk they use leaves a horrible after taste that has a very off putting taste. Won’t be back due to staff & just generally underwhelmed by this coffee shop.

service wasn’t the best but i get it, there was also a huge line shortly after us so it’s understandable. coffee is pretty good though