Island Cafe

Amazing Place! I wouldnt eat anywhere else... We Live 1-1/2 hours away and will make this a regular stop just to have great food and the staff are so friendly and welcoming here...
We had everything from gator bites through the philly sub and hot italian with the kids mac n cheese and burger and finished with ice cream and the AMAZING "FRIED KEY LIME PIE"!!!!
Get Here And Enjoy What A Real Homestyle Diner Tastes Like and Should Be...
Oohh.. I almost forgot... we took home some chicken soup and IT TASTED LIKE A Little Old Southern Lady Had Hand Made The Soup From The Morning and Was DELICIOUS...
The Respect they showed Firemen coming in to eat from out of town to help in the 100 acre blaze was touching and a blessing... see yall soon!!!

Little place and our lunch was great. I had crab melt on rye. Great service fast super clean. Very easy place to catch a great local bite.

We love this place. They make great food and have great service. They also make box lunches for your fishing trips. The locals eat here and love it too.

Good food at reasonable prices. I had the oyster Po Boy which was very good and my wife had the Fish Reuben which she enjoyed. A bottle Yuengling beer provided cold relief.

Overall, a very nice place with good food.

My boyfriend and I were around the area and I was really in the mood for some gator. I had the gator tacos and fries and he had the gator basket. We also shared the calamari. It was a good lunch after our kayaking adventure.

Awesome crabcakes and fries. The alligator bites my husband had were also great. Very cool town. Amazing service.

Clean, great value and service 👌 and hot tasty 😋 food

Wonderful! Gator bites were so good I had two (appetizer size) orders! Hubby had New England clam chowder and a very good burger recommended by our waiter. Unfortunately, we did not get his name, but he was one of the nicest and hardest-working young men we've met in ages. (The one that was wearing a gold-colored long-sleeved tshirt and has longish, blond hair.) He made our literally rainy day bright and cheerful!

Then I had to go to the bathroom, which was all the way on the other side of the restaurant, and I got lost coming and going because of all the truly fanciful and unique decor.

We will certainly return many times, and would like management to pass our compliments on to our waiter.

Loved this quaint Cafe. Food was very good and service was excellent. Must stop in Everglades City.

We drove 40 minutes from Marco Island and we were not disappointed. Our waiter was great, the food came out fast, hot and delicious. We did not leave hungry. Great customer service, friendly staff, awesome place in a cool little town. We will return for more.