Belmar Bakery

Decent prices. Friendly staff. The cookies are really good. Will definitely return! Locally owned..

This bakery has given me countless birthday cake, cookie cakes, and cookies that have been perfect and exactly what I wanted! The ingredients are natural and the service is fantastic, they always make me feel welcome. I never leave without a smile and the prices are the lowest I’ve seen!

While we have enjoyed Belmar Bakery in the past and have ordered many cakes from them over the years, I would NOT recommend having a birthday party with them. I have four children and each year they are free to choose where we have their party. This year my daughter chose the bakery to have her 12th birthday. The decorating was fun and they enjoyed it but the owner's deplorable attitude was not enjoyable. Perhaps overwhelmed by volume, life, or just an ordinary bad day her smug demeanor was unprofessional and disgusting. The way in which she spoke to her staff was unacceptable. There are several options for birthday party venues in town I recommend choosing somewhere else. To her crew, hang in there! You all are doing a great job under stress.

Belmar Bakery is amazing! They made me an ender dragon cake from mincraft! I'm so happy with this cake, thank you belmar!

They make the best cakes, pies, cookies. I have had to ask for rush orders lately and they have always been done for me. Beautiful cakes. We ordered
Cheesecake and Pies for Thanksgiving. Again they were amazing.

I’ve had cookies from Belmar that are great and needed a last minute cake person as mine was feeling ill and I didn’t want to chance anything during a pandemic. The ordering process was easy, but the cake I asked for and the cake I received only vaguely resembled each other. I wish they would have told me they weren’t good at doing naked cakes before I finalized my order, I sent them a picture and everything :/

Definitely my favorite bakery in town. The staff is excellent. The food always stands out from the rest. The whole experience is one to repeat. Ownership skills are subpar on separating personal feelings when former employees transition over to just being paying customers. But overall it's a great place to get some good grub. Definitely will be returning for goodness.

Used to love this place. Designs on cookies in the show cases are amazing.. Sadly the last 2 times we have went the cookies tasted old. Really sad because this used to be my family's go to bakery!

Fantastic baked good and excellent service! I made a very last minute order for 2 dozen cupcakes and they busted their behinds to get it done! (It was definitely my fault; I should have been more prepared) but they went the extra mile and got it done. They were delicious and surprisingly inexpensive too. Don’t shop around, just go with Belmar.

I’ve been buying cakes from Belmar’s Bakery for a couple of years now and they normally do an amazing job-I’ve actually referred them to many people. However the past two times I ordered a cake from there it was absolutely nothing like what I had asked for. 😕 Sent pictures and everything. Won’t be buying anymore cakes from here anymore.