Search

Amenities

  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Outdoor seating
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in

Art of Pie Cafe Reviews - 70

4.8
Quality
5.0
Location
5.0
Price
4.0
Service
4.5
Chloe Warrell

Such great food and a home-y feeling. The staff is super nice !

Theresa Myers

I went in for the first time for the new Shippensburg Police Chief's Meet and Greet. I had a slice of the blueberry pie with a crumb crust topping. It was delicious. I ordered a whole one to be made to take up to my in-laws for July 4th. They loved it.

My husband's birthday is Monday. I asked him if he wanted pie or cake. He said peach or cherry pie. I called and ordered a whole peach pie with a regular crust this time to pick up Saturday. I can't wait to taste it.

My husband would like a Montgomery pie but he is picky about the syrup used to make it. I have gotten him ones around town and he is never satisfied. I don't eat it so I couldn't tell you if it is just him or if the pies were really awful.

I am going to ask the Art of Pie Cafe owner if I get the recipe my husband like's from his mother passed down from his deceased grandmother, if she will make it for me. I sure hope so.

Heather Gray

I love walking here and getting coffee or something small to eat every once in a while!

Janeen Stoner

The key lime pie is where it’s at!! The service was on point and I recommend it to all locals and visitors alike.

Michael Dooner

Really good coffee. My wife loved her BLT and cupcakes!

Brittni Fuller

Great!! I had the summer corn soup and Cuban. Delicious! The desserts all look so good. Good prices too. Will be stopping by again.

christalynn schulz

Good coffee, delicious cupcakes, a revolving menu of cakes, cheesecake, pie. I brought my daughter here to have a girl's day and we were very happy, we've returned twice to bring home the cupcakes to share.

Kristina Mowen (Tina)

This place is a gem! Freshly made treats, bagles, soups and more!

Great for breakfast, lunch, or to appease your sweet tooth! The back patio is awesome in the warmer weather.

Barbara Motichka

This is the greatest find in Shippensburg. One of my co-workers raved about it so we tried it. Everything is made to order and fresh. The staff is amazing an the owner is wonderful. They will never disappoint! If you are visiting the area and aren't sure where to stop, make this a have to you will enjoy. Ambiance, freshness, originality and quality.

Joy J

LOVE the Nutella cheesecake and chai latte! So yummy! Also, I really enjoyed eating outside during the warmer weather. So glad this place opened up in Shippensburg! The owner is super friendly and the staff as well! Definitely recommend this delightful bakery/cafe!

Add Review

Cleanliness
Comfort
Staff
Facilities
Your Score
Click here or drop files to upload