Search
4.5

49 reviews

Review of New Story Coffee House

New Story Coffee House: a cozy and inviting coffee shop located on East Main Street in Mt. Pleasant, Pennsylvania. This specialty coffee house offers a variety of quick eats and serves the highest quality of coffee. The owners believe that their community deserves the best, and they strive to provide just that.

The coffee served at New Story Coffee House is fresh and of the highest quality. The owners are knowledgeable and passionate about coffee, and it shows in every cup they serve. Customers rave about the signature drinks, and the homemade muffins are a must-try. The coffee shop also offers smoothies and teas for those who prefer a different beverage.

The atmosphere at New Story Coffee House is cozy and welcoming. The bohemian feel of the coffee shop adds to its charm, and customers appreciate the friendly and upbeat service. The owners are always happy to chat and make recommendations for those who are unsure of what to order.

New Story Coffee House is open Wednesday through Sunday, with varying hours each day. The coffee shop is closed on Mondays and Tuesdays. Customers appreciate the fair prices and speedy service, especially considering the handcrafted and small-batched nature of the coffee. The coffee shop does not have outside seating yet, but customers are looking forward to the addition of this feature in the future.

If you're in the Mt. Pleasant area and love coffee, be sure to stop by New Story Coffee House. The owners are friendly, the coffee is delicious, and the atmosphere is cozy and inviting. It's no wonder that this coffee shop is a favorite among locals.

From the business

"New Story Coffee House is a specialty coffee house with quick eats where we value people and serve the highest quality of coffee because we believe our community deserves it."

Amenities

  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in

New Story Coffee House Reviews - 49

4.5
Quality
5.0
Location
5.0
Price
4.0
Service
4.5
chris jones

It's a really nice cozy coffee house. They are new but great. They take the time out to really appreciate the brew of coffee. Honestly, New Story Coffee House is the place you need to stop into if you visit Mt. Pleasant. They legit take their time into making sure the coffee is perfect. So everytime you do go back, because you will go back, your type of drink will be made exactly the same way everytime. It will be fantastic, you will get excellent service, and you will have the best place locally to get your coffee.

They help out in the community as well. They donated a ton of coffee to the helpers of that Laurelville Retreat Center fire cleanup. Just really great people.

You might have a routine of stopping at Dunkin donuts or somewhere else every morning to get your drink, but you need to change it up and give this place a shot. They are fantastic people who simply enjoy the art of a brew. They have great prices and a very good variety of drinks as well.

Don't hesitate into going to this place. Just go and you won't regret it. You'll just wish they've been around your entire life so you're coffee needs would've been complete.

Kinara Patel

Must try the in-house flavors for coffee ❤️. I tried peppermint and was not at all overpowering. The coffee was just right!

R. Mali Elizabeth Sicard

Stopped here on a quick detour during a long road trip and it was just an amazing experience. The raspberries used in their specialty coffees and muffins are fresh and from a local farm. Highly recommend.❤️❤️

lizzy e

This is by far the best coffee I've had from a small shop! It has amazing flavor and doesn't taste burnt or watered down like most in greensburg! I highly recommend

Dana Wallace

Great quaint coffee house. Family owned and operated. Places to sit and enjoy coffee and conversation. We will return again.

Eric Hansel

Very nice little coffee shop. Owners are super friendly. My daughter is a Starbucks fan but liked the drink she got here better which is high praise!

Krystina Long

Lack of choices and no food menu just flavorless coffee, staff unprofessional and I felt very judged. Stuffy environment all around and bland. For the price they should have better options/flavor/attitude.

Bolana Schofield

So much potential! My latte tasted amazing and our barista was very friendly. I enjoyed it and can't wait to see how they expand in the coming months

Murry Evans

Great coffee. Great people.

Dawn C

This place is super cute. Great service and knowledge staff. The coffee was delicious. I can't wait to go back and see how they grow.

Add Review

Cleanliness
Comfort
Staff
Facilities
Your Score
Click here or drop files to upload