Carini Brick Oven Cafe

What a rip off. $14 for the smallest and thinnest pizza I ever had, better off with DiGiorno. When I was handed the box I thought it was empty. They changed their name to Cafe and over season with Oregano and jack up their prices. I bet the other reviews are the owners because this was a waste. Calamari was cooked well but they gave us no sauce for it, and the portion was tiny. I will not be back again. This was an Insult to NY Brick Oven Pizza. I grew up in NY and this pizza even folded was still not as thick as a NY slice.

Absolutely lights out quality, fresh and delicious! Nice atmosphere to sit and enjoy the way things ought to be when you dine out! Accommodated a party of 7 walk-in and crushed it for us! We got 4 appetizers, 4 large pies, requested to try their cutlet a la carte and ordered all 5 gelato flavors and they nailed everything! We grabbed a Freddo matcha and a flat white to go and watched them whip both up and once again…knock out punch on both! The matcha was extremely fresh and flavorful! The service was outstanding! We WILL be back! A diamond in the rough out here in the hills of Pa!

First of all, ALL PRAISES TO THE MOST HIGH! As usual, CARINI always comes thru! Coming from the Bronx, pizza was always all around me. So altho not being my usual go-to shop, i was impressed by their selection and FRESHNESS. The pizza man KNOWS WHAT HE'S DOING. Not to s*** on the other shop(brother brunos), but Carinis IS HANDS DOWN the best shop around Hemlock... i used to rock with Brunos, but Carinis blew them out the water. Yeah, you pay for what you get; but living in Hemlock, if you could afford an AUDI, you could afford Carinis...

Wide selection of food and drinks and the best coffee. ALWAYS excellent service , staff is friendly and helfpul. The owner is so kind. Would always reccomend! Try the old world, trust me. 😊

I was told to go there for pizza but I actually had an entree and had a spicy seafood linguine dish the sauce was way too watery. Had to spray and wash my shirt it what about minute I was way too wet should have been thicker and more flavorful. Had the bruschetta, and I could say was not the best I ever had. What are the Philly cheesesteak to go and it was on some kind of around fluffy bread and barely had any provolone in there and it tastes more like barbecue sauce I'm going to add a photo

The pizza was absolutely amazing. My friends and I loved everything we tried. Make sure to try their house made gelato. 🤤

Descent food for the most part, but not worth the horrific attitude of those who work there. Poor customer service and no attention to detail. I gave it a few chances, but refuse to go back or order take-out again.

On Saturday night I came in with my mother, father and some friends. We ordered a few entrees and two brick oven pies! Our visit was more than delightful. Our waitress Bre was more than accommodating and made sure our table had everything we needed. Food was just perfect and delicious. Will visit again with more friends! Thank you!

This is one of the best restaurants around. Think they need to do better in timely manner of serving food and food should be served hot on hot plates.

Stopped here in the middle of a road trip and have no regrets! Service was amazing, as was the food. HIGHLY recommend the gelato! Also - perfect pizza. Wasn’t greasy which is usually my complaint!
The restaurant looks really cute and the staff seems to all work together well. Special thanks to Abigael, you were a wonderful server and we enjoyed our time in your section! (: