Cafe Dewitt

Great food, long wait. Each time I've been here, there is a 30-45 minute wait, and ordering takes another 45 minutes until food arrives on your plate. When it does come, however, it's really great. I like to come here when I'm with a friend that I want to spend time with, but never when I'm in a hurry. The local ingredients are awesome, but their eggs Benedict killllls me, though, because the sauce doesn't taste like a real hollandaise sauce and it's served on regular bread, vs. an English muffin.

Great cafe! Handled Covid restrictions well! Delicious pulled pork sandwich and taco special! Friendly Chef and waiter. Gave us recommendations for local wineries and breweries. High quality ingredients used at a reasonable price!

We came here for brunch on a Saturday. Free street parking right outside. There was about a 4 minute wait to get seated and about 30 to get our food. Highly recommend the omelette carol and the fresh squeezed orange juicy. Cozy little spot that serves organic and locally grown foods. Delicious!

Perfect breakfast! Locally sourced, fresh and quick. We both had specials. I had avocado toast with fried eggs ( instead of scrambled) and ordered a side of basil hazelnut pesto. DH had a breakfast sandwich with roasted potatoes that he raved about. A home run for us. Service was good and the blackboard was easily readable. (An earlier reviewer commented on illegible writing).

The food: great. The folks: best.
put it on the gram, fam

I was a bit disappointed with my meal here. I used to frequent Café DeWitt because it was consistently good. This last time I ate here Iordered a special sandwich on the blackboard. I thought the sandwich was flavorless. My friend felt the same way and they had a standard menu item which leads me to believe we either came on an off day or the quality or preparation has declined. The service was consistent and great! I hope to have a better experience here next time, but this is no longer at the top of my list for places to eat for lunch.

Our go-to breakfast spot in Ithaca. If you like french toast, get it here and prepare to have your mind blown. Friendly staff in a cute area full of Ithaca characters. I've never had lunch here, but if it is half as good as the breakfast you should be fine.

This place doesn't have it together yet. One menu around a corner so you have to memorize what you want, omelette fillings too large to get in one cut, extremely limited drink selection for a cafe. It could be a lot better with better organization

Great breakfast and lunch spot with a special brunch menu on the weekends. It gets very busy on the weekends so expect a wait, but it's worth it. Awesome staff, interesting location in a historic building. Try the morning glory sandwich, which you can get with avocado instead of bacon

Simple but delicious (made with care) breakfast, fast service. We liked it a lot.