Search
4.5

100 reviews

Amenities

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible restroom
  • Wheelchair accessible seating
  • Outdoor seating
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in

Fellow Mountain Cafe Reviews - 100

4.5
Quality
5.0
Location
5.0
Price
4.0
Service
4.5
Rebecca Strassberg

kylie and jacob who work there are like local celebrities! the cinnamon roll was unreal, as you've read a million times, coffee was great, and it's a beautiful place! what else could you want?

Elena Wolfe

Really nice stop for pastries and coffee. The egg sandwich was light and the brioche was so delicate, the parfait was perfectly balanced with sweet and crunch.

Gracie P

Great local cafe with very good baked good and coffee. A little disappointing with the menu changes as of late. The old menu was working so well, not sure why staples like their egg sandwich were changed to the extent that they were.

The blonde girl behind the counter has the patience of a saint. People forget they’re interacting with humans while ordering and asking questions and she handles them with nothing but patience, kindness and a smile.

Thanks to her and the cinnamon buns, it’s a staple!

Amanda Bezerra

Super cute cafe with great lattes, pastries, and breakfast options! I have tried their avocado toast, cinnamon bun, and pistachio chocolate cake. All absolutely delicious! Pets are allowed in their outdoor seating area which is a plus!

Ella Z

Coffee is nice and also service. It is nice seat outside to see the hunter mountain and enjoy the fresh air. They have lots of tea choices too.

Akshada Shinde

Their egg sandwich with freshly baked brioche buns is mouth watering. You can’t stop yourself from having more. Loved their coffee too!!

Marina Browe

Food here is awesome. Staff are super nice. Interior design on point. 10/10 highly recommend.

I come here anytime I’m in the Catskills and it never disappoints. Their focaccia is so crispy on the outside and chewy fluffy on the inside. They offer ice cream in the summer which is my favorite.

Breakfast or lunch you can’t go wrong. I love this place.

They also have cute merch.

Eric Koivisto

The sea salt focaccia is back!!! And the coffee is the best on the mountain. Can’t wait for sit-down breakfasts again in Feb and great to see some regular items added to the menu. And the take out options are really good.

Michael

We've been patrons of Fellow since they first opened. The coffee w/ cinnamon bun is worthy of a visit alone. Excellent espresso and fresh homemade pastries that aren't all sugar and fake frosting. The menu has grown and everything is pretty good and they have a small selection of local produce for sale including beers/ciders. Most disappointing though is no more sourdough! It was the best in the Catskills (behind Breadfolks), hope it comes back.

Teo Evtimova

This place makes probably the best cappuccino in the catskills. The snacks are freshly made and delicious. The space is clean, remodeled and welcoming. The crowd is mostly city people. It definately has a Brooklyn vibe.

Add Review

Cleanliness
Comfort
Staff
Facilities
Your Score
Click here or drop files to upload